The Hall Effect Discovery of 1879 Explained
On 28 October 1879, a graduate student at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore watched the needle of a sensitive galvanometer move by a small but steady amount. The needle was wired to two points on opposite edges of a strip of gold leaf. Current flowed along the strip, and the strip sat between the poles of an electromagnet. When the magnet was switched on, a voltage appeared across the width of the strip. When the magnet was reversed, the voltage reversed. The student was Edwin Herbert Hall, he was 23 years old (he was born on 7 November 1855), and the effect he had just measured now carries his name.
The Hall effect sounds like a small footnote in the history of electricity. It is not. It corrected a statement by James Clerk Maxwell, gave physicists a direct way to count charge carriers inside a material, helped reveal (decades later) that some materials conduct with what behave like positive charges, and became the working principle behind magnetic sensors found in cars, phones, laptops, and industrial machines. A century after Hall, a low-temperature version of the same measurement produced a Nobel Prize and a new standard of electrical resistance.
This article walks through the question Hall set out to answer, how he built the experiment, what went wrong first, what he actually saw, and why the result still matters.
The question: does a magnet push the wire or the current?
By the 1870s, physicists knew well that a wire carrying a current feels a force in a magnetic field. That was the basis of electric motors and of the work by Ampère and Faraday earlier in the century. (For the background, see our explainer on the Oersted electromagnetism discovery, which first linked current and magnetism in 1820.)
What nobody knew was what the magnet was acting on. Was the force applied to the metal of the wire, which then dragged the current along with it? Or did the force act on the electric current itself, which then pushed on the wire?
James Clerk Maxwell had taken a position on this in his Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism, published in 1873. In the first edition, he wrote that the mechanical force urging a conductor carrying a current across magnetic lines of force acts "not on the electric current, but on the conductor which carries it." Maxwell's view was reasonable given what was known at the time. Nobody had detected any sign that a magnetic field could rearrange a current inside a stationary conductor.
Hall read this passage while studying Maxwell's book and was not convinced. If the magnet really pushed on the current, he reasoned, then a current flowing along a fixed conductor in a magnetic field should be crowded toward one side. That crowding might show up as a change in the conductor's resistance, or as a measurable voltage across it.
His adviser was Henry Augustus Rowland, one of the leading American physicists of the era, who doubted Maxwell's claim and had himself made a hasty experiment on the question without success. Rowland had not given up on the idea, and he encouraged Hall to try again.
For broader context on Maxwell's framework, see Maxwell's electromagnetic theory.
Why the question was hard to answer in 1879
Several things made Hall's search difficult.
Nobody knew what a current was. The electron would not be identified until J. J. Thomson's cathode ray experiments in 1897, eighteen years later. (See Thomson's cathode ray experiment.) Hall had no picture of tiny charged particles drifting through metal. He was testing whether "the current" behaved like a thing that could be pushed sideways, without knowing what it was made of.
The expected signal was minute. In ordinary metals, the voltage that appears across a conductor in a magnetic field is extremely small. The effect scales inversely with the number of charge carriers per unit volume, and metals have an enormous number of them. Instruments of the 1870s were near the limit of what could detect it.
Magnets were weak. Hall had electromagnets, but not the strong, uniform fields available to later laboratories.
Other effects could mask it. Heating, contact voltages at junctions, and slight misalignment of the measuring points could all produce stray readings larger than the effect Hall was hunting.
The first attempt: looking for a change in resistance
Hall's first idea was indirect. If the magnet pushed the current toward one side of a wire, the current would effectively use less of the wire's cross-section, and the resistance should rise. He tried to measure whether a conductor showed a higher resistance when placed in a magnetic field.
This attempt did not produce a convincing result. The change in resistance that a magnetic field causes in ordinary metals (now called magnetoresistance) is small and hard to separate from temperature changes. Hall turned to a more direct approach.
The second attempt: measuring a sideways voltage
Hall's improved plan was to look for a voltage across the conductor, perpendicular to the direction of current flow. If the magnet pushed the current sideways, then charge would build up on one edge of the conductor until the resulting electric field balanced the magnetic push. That buildup should appear as a steady voltage between the two edges.
The setup had these parts:
- Two electromagnet poles facing each other, producing a field across a small gap.
- A thin conductor placed in that gap, with the field passing through its flat face.
- A battery driving a current along the length of the conductor.
- Two contacts on opposite edges of the conductor, placed so that, with no magnetic field, there was no voltage between them.
- A sensitive galvanometer wired between those two contacts.
The trick was choosing where to place the edge contacts. Hall had to find two points on opposite sides of the strip that sat at the same electrical potential when the magnet was off. Only then would any voltage that appeared when the magnet was switched on be attributable to the field.
Earlier trials, including Rowland's, used a thick metal strip, which was too thick for the signal to show. The Hall voltage for a given current is larger in thinner conductors, because it varies inversely with thickness. On Rowland's suggestion, Hall switched to a strip of gold leaf mounted on a glass plate. Gold leaf is extraordinarily thin, which compensated for the modest strength of his magnet.
What Hall saw
With the gold leaf in place, Hall found what he was looking for. Switching on the electromagnet caused a small, steady deflection of the galvanometer, and the deflection held as long as the magnet stayed on. Reversing the direction of the magnetic field reversed the deflection. Reversing the current also reversed it. The voltage appeared at right angles to both the current and the magnetic field, exactly what one would expect if the magnet pushed sideways on the current.
Hall published his findings in 1879 under the title "On a New Action of the Magnet on Electric Currents" in the American Journal of Mathematics (volume 2, number 3, pages 287–292), a journal then edited at Johns Hopkins. Further accounts followed in March 1880 in the American Journal of Science (volume 19, pages 200–205) and the Philosophical Magazine (volume 9, pages 225–230). He earned his PhD from Johns Hopkins in 1880.
The result meant Maxwell's statement in the Treatise was wrong on that specific point. The magnet did act on the current itself, not just on the material that carried it. After Maxwell's death in 1879, the second edition of the Treatise carried an editor's footnote acknowledging that Hall's finding contradicted the original statement.
| What Hall varied | What happened to the sideways voltage |
|---|---|
| Magnet off | No steady voltage across the strip |
| Magnet on | Small, steady voltage appeared |
| Magnetic field reversed | Voltage reversed sign |
| Current reversed | Voltage reversed sign |
| Thicker conductor | Effect harder to detect |
The pattern of sign reversals ruled out simple heating or contact voltages, which would not flip with the field direction. The table summarizes the qualitative pattern; Hall's published papers give the detailed deflections.
What the Hall effect is, in modern terms
Hall effect: the appearance of a voltage across a current-carrying conductor when a magnetic field is applied perpendicular to the current. That voltage is perpendicular to both the current and the field.
Today the explanation runs as follows. A current is a flow of charged particles. Any moving charge in a magnetic field feels a sideways push called the Lorentz force. Inside a conductor, this push nudges the moving charges toward one edge. As they pile up on that edge, they leave the opposite edge with the opposite net charge. The separated charges create an electric field across the conductor. Within a tiny fraction of a second, this electric field grows strong enough to exactly balance the magnetic push, and the sideways drift stops. What remains is a steady voltage across the conductor: the Hall voltage.
The size of the Hall voltage depends on four things:
- The current. More current means more moving charges being pushed.
- The magnetic field strength. A stronger field pushes harder.
- The thickness of the conductor (in the direction of the field). Thinner conductors produce larger Hall voltages for the same current.
- The density of charge carriers. Fewer carriers per unit volume means each must move faster to carry the same current, so each feels a larger push. The Hall voltage is inversely proportional to carrier density.
That fourth point is the reason Hall's measurement was so difficult in gold and so easy, decades later, in semiconductors. Metals have an enormous carrier density, so their Hall voltages are tiny. Semiconductors have far fewer carriers, so their Hall voltages can be orders of magnitude larger under the same conditions.
The sign surprise: when the effect reverses
The Hall voltage has a sign, and in a simple picture that sign tells you whether the carriers are positive or negative. If the carriers are negative electrons, they pile up on one edge. If the carriers are positive, they pile up on the opposite edge, and the voltage flips.
Hall tested other metals after gold. In his 1880 papers he reported that silver, nickel, tin and platinum behaved like gold, differing only in degree, but that in iron the direction of the transverse current was reversed. He had been prepared for something unusual in iron (Rowland had predicted it), but he was puzzled that iron and nickel, both strongly magnetic, gave opposite signs. At the time there was no theory to explain any of this, because nobody yet knew that current in metals is carried by electrons.
Two different explanations eventually emerged. In some nonmagnetic metals and semiconductors, the behavior of electrons in a nearly full energy band is best described as the motion of missing electrons, called holes, which act like positive charges. Quantum band theory in the late 1920s and early 1930s explained why some metals, such as zinc and cadmium, have a positive ordinary Hall coefficient. The Hall effect is one of the most direct experimental ways to tell whether a material conducts mainly by electrons or by holes. In semiconductor manufacturing, this distinction is the difference between n-type and p-type material, the two building blocks of transistors and diodes.
Iron's reversal is a different story. In ferromagnets the Hall voltage has an extra contribution tied to the material's own magnetization, the anomalous Hall effect described below, and fully understanding it took more than a century.
So Hall's measurement did more than correct Maxwell. It turned out to be a window into the internal quantum structure of solids, decades before anyone had the theory to interpret what that window showed.
Hall's other discoveries
Hall continued to investigate magnetic and thermal effects in conductors for much of his career. He moved to Harvard University in 1881 and stayed there for decades. Among the related effects he studied is what is now called the anomalous Hall effect: in ferromagnetic materials such as iron, the Hall voltage is far larger than the ordinary effect would predict and depends on the material's own magnetization, not only on the applied field. A full theoretical understanding of the anomalous Hall effect took more than a century and is still an active topic in condensed matter physics.
Common misconceptions about the Hall effect
"Hall discovered that magnets affect currents." Not quite. Forces between currents and magnets were known since the 1820s. Hall's discovery was narrower and more precise: that a magnet acts on the current inside a stationary conductor, producing a measurable transverse voltage.
"Hall knew he was seeing electrons being pushed." He did not. The electron was not identified until 1897. Hall's interpretation was framed in terms of the current itself. The particle picture came later.
"The Hall effect only works in metals." It works in any conductor, including semiconductors, where it is much larger and far more useful. It also appears in plasmas and in two-dimensional electron systems.
"The Hall voltage is the same as the motor force." They are related but distinct. The motor force is the net push on the whole wire. The Hall voltage is the internal electrical consequence of the charges being shoved to one side. In a sense, the Hall voltage is what transmits the magnetic push from the moving charges to the body of the conductor.
A century later: the quantum Hall effect
In 1980, the German physicist Klaus von Klitzing measured the Hall effect under extreme conditions: very strong magnetic fields, temperatures just a few degrees above absolute zero, and very clean samples in which electrons are confined to move in a two-dimensional layer at a semiconductor interface.
Under those conditions, the Hall resistance did not change smoothly as the field changed. Instead it formed a series of flat plateaus. The values on those plateaus could be expressed with extraordinary precision in terms of just two fundamental constants, the elementary charge and Planck's constant, divided by a whole number. The values did not depend on the size, shape, or exact composition of the sample.
Von Klitzing received the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1985 for this discovery of the quantized Hall effect. Because the plateau values depend only on fundamental constants, the quantum Hall effect became the basis of an international standard for electrical resistance. The related combination of constants is called the von Klitzing constant.
The story continued. In 1982, Daniel Tsui and Horst Störmer, with theoretical interpretation by Robert Laughlin, discovered the fractional quantum Hall effect, in which plateaus appear at fractional values. That work earned the 1998 Nobel Prize in Physics. Research on topological materials, which grew partly out of quantum Hall physics, remains one of the most active areas of modern physics. A gold-leaf experiment by a graduate student in Baltimore sits at the root of this entire family tree.
Where the Hall effect is used today
The Hall effect stayed mostly a laboratory curiosity until semiconductors arrived. Because semiconductors produce much larger Hall voltages than metals, it became practical in the mid-20th century to build small, cheap, robust sensors around it. A Hall effect sensor is a device that outputs a voltage proportional to the magnetic field passing through it.
Hall sensors are now produced in enormous numbers, and common uses include:
- Automotive systems. Crankshaft and camshaft position sensing for ignition timing, wheel-speed sensing for anti-lock brakes, and throttle and pedal position sensors.
- Brushless DC motors. Hall sensors tell the motor controller where the rotor's magnets are, so it can switch the coils at the right moment. This includes computer cooling fans and many electric-vehicle and appliance motors.
- Consumer electronics. Detecting whether a laptop lid or phone case is closed, and contributing to electronic compasses in phones.
- Current sensing. Measuring the magnetic field around a wire to measure the current in it without breaking the circuit, which is useful in power supplies and battery management.
- Contactless switches and keyboards. Hall-effect keyboard switches and joysticks avoid physical wear on electrical contacts.
In research and industry, the Hall measurement remains the standard way to characterize a semiconductor wafer. By measuring the Hall voltage at a known current and field, engineers can calculate the carrier density and determine whether the material is n-type or p-type. Combined with a resistivity measurement, it also yields the carrier mobility, a key figure for transistor performance.
Spacecraft use a different device with the same name. Hall-effect thrusters use crossed electric and magnetic fields to trap electrons and accelerate ions of a propellant such as xenon, producing thrust efficiently for satellites and deep-space missions. The physics of charges being pushed sideways by a magnetic field is the common thread.
Why the experiment mattered
The Hall experiment is a good example of how a carefully posed narrow question can open far wider territory. Hall did not set out to invent a sensor or found a branch of quantum physics. He set out to check whether one sentence in Maxwell's book was right. To do that, he needed a conductor thin enough, a galvanometer sensitive enough, and a method for zeroing out stray voltages carefully enough to detect a signal at the edge of what was measurable.
The experiment also shows the value of pushing back on authority with evidence. Maxwell was the most important theoretical physicist of the age, and his statement was a sensible inference. Hall and Rowland treated it as a claim that could be tested rather than settled by reputation. Maxwell himself died in November 1879, the same year as Hall's discovery.
Finally, the experiment illustrates how measurements can outrun theory. Hall's puzzling sign results, and the unexpectedly large effect in iron, sat unexplained for decades until quantum mechanics gave physicists the concept of holes and, much later, a theory of the anomalous Hall effect. The data were right all along. The theory simply had not caught up.
For more on how magnetic fields arise and act on matter, see our explainer on how magnetism works. For another case where a precise electrical measurement revealed something fundamental, see the Millikan oil drop experiment.
Key takeaways
- In 1879, Edwin Hall, a graduate student under Henry Rowland at Johns Hopkins, detected a voltage across a current-carrying gold leaf placed in a magnetic field.
- The voltage was perpendicular to both the current and the field, and it reversed when either was reversed.
- The result contradicted a statement in Maxwell's 1873 Treatise that a magnetic force acts on the conductor rather than on the current.
- The Hall voltage is inversely proportional to the density of charge carriers, which made it tiny in metals and large in semiconductors.
- Hall found in 1880 that iron gave the opposite sign to gold, silver, nickel, tin and platinum; later work attributed positive signs in some metals to holes and iron's behavior to magnetization (the anomalous Hall effect).
- Klaus von Klitzing's 1980 discovery of the quantum Hall effect earned the 1985 Nobel Prize and created a resistance standard based on fundamental constants.
- Hall sensors are now used in cars, motors, phones, keyboards, and current meters.
Sources
- Hall, E. H. (1879). "On a New Action of the Magnet on Electric Currents." American Journal of Mathematics, 2(3), 287–292. JSTOR
- Hall, E. H. (1880). "On a New Action of the Magnet on Electric Currents." American Journal of Science, 19, 200–205.
- Wikipedia - Edwin Hall
- Wikipedia - Hall effect
- Johns Hopkins Arts & Sciences Magazine - The Hall Effect (2019)
- National Academy of Sciences - Biographical Memoir of Edwin Herbert Hall
- University of Utah - Discovery of the Hall Effect (historical review)
- NobelPrize.org - Klaus von Klitzing, Physics 1985
- NobelPrize.org - Press release, Physics 1985
- Wikipedia - Hall effect sensor
FAQ
Q: Who discovered the Hall effect and when?
A: Edwin Herbert Hall discovered it in 1879 while working on his doctoral research at Johns Hopkins University under Henry Augustus Rowland. He published the result that year and received his PhD in 1880.
Q: Why did Hall use gold leaf instead of a thicker metal strip?
A: The Hall voltage is larger in thinner conductors carrying the same current. His first conductor was too thick for the weak magnets of the time to produce a detectable effect. Gold leaf is extremely thin, which raised the signal enough for his galvanometer to register it.
Q: What did the Hall effect prove about Maxwell's theory?
A: It showed that one specific claim in Maxwell's 1873 Treatise was wrong. Maxwell wrote that the magnetic force acts on the conductor rather than on the current. Hall's measurement showed the magnet acts on the current inside a fixed conductor, pushing it sideways and producing a transverse voltage.
Q: Why is the Hall effect much stronger in semiconductors than in metals?
A: The Hall voltage is inversely proportional to the number of charge carriers per unit volume. Metals have an enormous carrier density, so each carrier moves slowly and the voltage is tiny. Semiconductors have far fewer carriers, so the same current requires faster carriers that feel a stronger sideways push.
Q: What is the quantum Hall effect?
A: It is a version of the Hall effect seen in two-dimensional electron systems at very low temperatures and strong magnetic fields. The Hall resistance forms flat plateaus whose values depend only on fundamental constants. Klaus von Klitzing discovered it in 1980 and won the 1985 Nobel Prize in Physics.
Q: Where are Hall effect sensors used?
A: They are used in car ignition timing and anti-lock brake wheel-speed sensors, brushless motors including computer fans, laptop lid and phone cover detection, contactless keyboard switches, and current meters that measure current without cutting the wire.
Read next:
Follow new articles
Add SciHub101 to your feed reader to see new science and technology stories.
About the Author
SciHub101 is an independent science and technology publication founded and edited by Buğra Sözeri, a software engineer and app developer based in Türkiye. AI tools assist with drafting and research. Source documentation in the existing archive is uneven, and articles are being reviewed and corrected. The Editorial Team byline identifies editorial responsibility; it does not certify specialist or independent human review. Where we compare products, anything built by our own team is labelled as such — see the editorial guidelines and About page for how corrections and disclosures work.
Related Articles
Hess's Balloon Flights: How Cosmic Rays Were Found (1912)
In 1912 Victor Hess carried electroscopes to 5,350 m in a balloon and found radiation rising with height. Here is how the flights worked and what they proved.