Digital Nomad Visa Countries Compared (2026 Data)

Photo: Ketut Subiyanto / Pexels
A digital nomad visa is a residence permit that lets a person live in a country while working for employers or clients somewhere else. Roughly 50 to 65 countries offer one in 2026, depending on how strictly the term is defined, and the rules differ more than the marketing suggests. The monthly income test alone runs from about €2,849 in Spain to €4,500 in Estonia. This article compares 14 popular programs, shows how the thresholds are calculated, and flags where published figures conflict.
Key takeaways
- Counts of nomad-visa countries range from "more than 48" to 66, because sources disagree on what qualifies as a dedicated program.
- Many thresholds are formulas tied to a national minimum wage or average salary, so they rise every January even when the law has not changed.
- Estonia, Portugal, and Spain sit at the demanding end of Europe in 2026, at €4,500, €3,680, and €2,849 a month respectively.
- Thailand's Destination Thailand Visa (DTV) tests savings, not income, and Malaysia splits its income bar between tech and non-tech workers.
- No visa in this comparison removes your home-country tax obligations, and most forbid working for local clients.
How many countries actually offer a nomad visa?
The honest answer is "between 48 and 66," and the gap is a matter of definition. The 2026 Digital Nomad Visa Index reports more than 50 countries with dedicated digital nomad or remote-work visas, while the EY Global Immigration Index counted more than 48 jurisdictions as of February 2026. Commercial trackers that also count general residence permits open to remote workers reach 60 or more.
The counting problem is similar to counting "national parks." Some countries create a permit with the words "digital nomad" in the title. Others let remote workers use a general temporary-residence route without a dedicated category. A tracker that counts both will always report a larger number than one that counts only the first.
The category is also young. The pandemic years changed things quickly, with Barbados announcing its Welcome Stamp on June 30, 2020 and Estonia widely credited as the first country to create a visa aimed specifically at digital nomads that same year.
The same index ranks Spain, Malta, Portugal, Germany, and Hungary as its top five, though its methodology is not described on the page that summarizes it. Treat any ranking as one weighting of factors, not a verdict.
The 2026 comparison table
The table lists what each program asked for in published 2026 guidance. Official portals are the authority, and several of the figures below are summaries from immigration-research sites that disagree with each other on details. Where a figure is disputed, the note says so.
| Country | Visa | Income or funds test (2026) | Duration | Source and note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Portugal | D8 | €3,680/month (4 × €920 minimum wage) | 1 year initial, renewable | Remote Work Europe, Mar 2026 |
| Spain | Digital Nomad Visa | €2,849/month (200% of minimum wage) | 1 or 3 years initial, up to 5 | Remote Work Europe, 2026 |
| Estonia | Digital Nomad Visa | €4,500/month gross, averaged over 6 months | Up to 12 months | Jobbatical, 2026; gross vs net disputed |
| Greece | Digital Nomad Visa | €3,500/month | 12-month visa, then a 2-year residence permit, renewable | Remote Work Europe, 2026; gross vs net disputed |
| Croatia | Digital Nomad Residence Permit | €3,622.50/month | Up to 18 months; extension rules differ by source | Remote Work Europe, 2026 |
| Italy | Digital Nomad Visa | About €25,500 to €28,000/year | 1 year, renewable | The Local, Remote Work Europe, 2026; figure disputed |
| Costa Rica | Digital Nomad Visa | $3,000/month for each of the prior 12 months | 1 year, renewable once | Published guidance, 2026 |
| Colombia | Digital Nomad (V) Visa | COP 5,252,715/month (3 × minimum wage) | Up to 2 years | Published guidance, 2026 |
| Brazil | VITEM XIV | $1,500/month or $18,000 in funds | 1 year, renewable once | Published guidance, 2026 |
| Thailand | Destination Thailand Visa | 500,000 THB in funds | 5-year visa, 180 days per entry | Thai embassy in Budapest page |
| Malaysia | DE Rantau Nomad Pass | $24,000/year (tech) or $60,000/year (non-tech) | 3 to 12 months, up to 24 total | MDEC FAQ v10.0, Aug 2026, as summarized |
| Indonesia | E33G Remote Worker KITAS | $60,000/year from foreign sources | 1 year | Published guidance, 2026 |
| UAE | Virtual Working Programme | $5,000/month | 1 year, renewable | UAE government portal, as summarized |
| Barbados | Welcome Stamp | $50,000/year | 12 months, reapply afterward | Visit Barbados official page |
Three patterns stand out. European programs tend to test monthly income, Latin American programs often test income or savings, and Thailand's DTV tests a lump sum instead of a salary. That last choice matters for freelancers with uneven earnings, because a bank balance is easier to show than a steady monthly pay slip.
Why the income number is not the whole test
A headline figure hides three details that decide whether you qualify: how it is calculated, over what window it is measured, and whether it is gross or net.
Most European thresholds are formulas. Portugal multiplies the national minimum wage by four, Spain doubles its monthly minimum wage (averaged across 14 payments), Colombia triples its monthly minimum wage, and Croatia sets the bar at 2.5 times the prior year's average net salary. The figures reset each January, so a threshold quoted in a 2024 blog post is probably wrong today.
| Country | Formula | Worked example (2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Portugal | 4 × monthly minimum wage | 4 × €920 = €3,680 |
| Spain | 200% of monthly minimum wage (€1,221 × 14 payments ÷ 12) | 2 × €1,424.50 = €2,849 |
| Colombia | 3 × monthly minimum wage | 3 × COP 1,750,905 = COP 5,252,715 |
| Croatia | 2.5 × prior-year average net salary | 2.5 × €1,449 = €3,622.50 |
The measurement window matters as much. Estonia asks applicants to document an average over the six months before applying. Colombia looks at the previous three months. Costa Rica asks for $3,000 in each of the 12 months before filing, which is the strictest of the three because a single weak month can sink the file.
The gross-versus-net question is the most common source of confusion. Estonia's official terminology is gross, but immigration advisers recommend meeting the bar in net pay to avoid disputes. Sources on Greece's €3,500 figure disagree on whether it is before or after tax. When a published figure is ambiguous, the safe reading is the stricter one.
For a broader look at why costs differ so much between places, see the data on countries with the highest cost of living, which shows how the same income stretches very differently from one destination to the next.
Portugal: still popular, no longer a tax shortcut
Portugal's D8 visa asks for €3,680 a month in 2026, which is four times the €920 national minimum wage. According to Remote Work Europe's March 2026 update, the formula did not change; the minimum wage did. The agency that processes applications, AIMA, applies the minimum wage in force on the appointment date, not the filing date. The same source reports add-ons of 50% for a spouse and 30% per child, which would put a four-person household near €7,728 a month. Only income from clients or employers outside Portugal counts.
The big change since the program launched is the tax regime. The old Non-Habitual Resident (NHR) scheme, which gave very low rates on many foreign income streams, was replaced by IFICI, sometimes called NHR 2.0. Advisory-firm summaries describe it as a 10-year regime with a 20% flat rate on income from eligible employment and self-employment activities in Portugal, and an exemption for much foreign-source income under conditions. The legal basis is Article 58-A of the Portuguese Statute of Tax Benefits.
The catch is eligibility. IFICI targets qualifying jobs and research and innovation activities, not remote work in general. Whether a remote employee of a foreign company qualifies depends on the sector and on how the income is classified, so the old assumption that any nomad can move to Lisbon and pay almost no tax no longer holds. A Portuguese tax adviser should confirm this before the move.
Portugal still ranks third in the 2026 Digital Nomad Visa Index, and it offers EU residence, a mild climate, and an established foreign community. Housing costs in Lisbon and Porto are a frequent complaint among newcomers, but published estimates of the increase vary too widely to quote here.
Spain: lower threshold, narrower tax break
Spain's visa came out of the 2022 Startup Act (Ley 28/2022) and now asks for €2,849 a month for a single applicant, up from €2,763 in 2025. The increase follows Royal Decree 126/2026, which raised the minimum wage. Remote Work Europe reports that dependents add 75% of the monthly minimum wage for the first and 25% for each further one, so family figures should be confirmed with a consulate.
Duration depends on where you apply. An applicant who files from outside Spain gets an initial one-year visa, while a visa-exempt applicant already in Spain can receive an initial three-year authorization. Renewals come in two-year steps up to five years in total, and renewal requires at least six months of presence in Spain each year. After five years of legal residence, long-term residency becomes possible.
Freelancers face an extra rule: no more than 20% of income can come from Spanish clients, so at least 80% must come from abroad. That is a structural difference from a standard work visa, and it means a nomad who picks up Spanish clients can break the terms.
The tax picture is narrower than many older guides suggest. Some of them still describe a 15% flat rate under the so-called Beckham Law. Current summaries describe a flat 24% on Spanish-source employment income up to €600,000 a year, with 47% above that, and generally no Spanish tax on foreign-sourced income. The election must be made within six months of registering with Social Security or starting qualifying work, and self-employed applicants usually do not qualify. Because the rules are precise and the window is short, this is a question for a Spanish tax professional.
Readers weighing Spain against other places on lifestyle grounds may find the quality-of-life index ranking a useful companion to the visa terms.
Estonia: the pioneer got more expensive
Estonia is usually credited with creating the first visa aimed specifically at digital nomads in 2020. In 2026 it also has one of the highest bars in Europe: €4,500 in monthly gross income, averaged over the six months before the application and earned from foreign sources. Published guidance describes the visa as a long-stay permit of up to 12 months, and it requires health insurance for the whole duration.
One detail helps applicants. Jobbatical reports that the Digital Nomad Visa does not count against Estonia's 2026 quota of 1,292 slots for non-EU work and business residence permits. The visa does not lead directly to permanent residence.
Older guides still cite a lower figure of €3,504. The practical reading is that €4,500 gross is the commonly reported 2026 figure, and the official portal is where the final answer lives.
Estonia's e-Residency program is a separate product. It gives a digital identity and the ability to run an EU company remotely, but it is not a residence permit and does not allow a person to live in the country.
Estonia also illustrates a theme running through this comparison: governments that attract remote workers also want to raise the quality of the applicant pool. The 2026 figure is about 28% higher than the €3,504 that older guides cite, a reminder that early-mover programs tighten once demand is proven.
Greece, Croatia, and Italy: the Mediterranean cluster
Greece asks for €3,500 a month, with add-ons reported at 20% for a spouse and 15% per child. Sources conflict on whether the figure is measured before or after tax. Remote Work Europe reports that since February 5, 2026, under Law 5275/2026, in-country applications are no longer accepted and applicants must apply at a Greek consulate. The visa is valid for 12 months, and a two-year residence permit, renewable in two-year periods, is then obtained in Greece.
Croatia's Digital Nomad Residence Permit is calculated against the average net salary. The 2026 figure is €3,622.50 a month, up from €3,295 in 2025, per the March 2026 Narodne novine publication cited by Remote Work Europe. Permits run for up to 18 months, and sources differ on whether and how they can be extended, so check the current police rules. A savings route also exists: €43,470 for a 12-month stay or €65,205 for 18 months, which are the monthly threshold multiplied by 12 or 18. Several sites still print the older €3,295 number.
Italy is the newest of the three. Reporting says consulates began accepting applications on March 18, 2026, though sources differ on which decree is the legal basis. The income test is annual and formula-based, at about three times the healthcare-exemption threshold. Sources give €25,500 in some places and €28,000 in others, so the figure is unsettled. Applicants are commonly asked for six months of prior remote-work history, a degree or three to five years of experience, health insurance covering the full stay, and proof of accommodation.
For readers choosing among these countries on infrastructure, the infrastructure rankings and the healthcare systems comparison cover two factors visa pages rarely mention.
Latin America: Costa Rica, Colombia, and Brazil
Costa Rica's visa is built on one idea: stable, documented income. Applicants show at least $3,000 a month in each of the 12 months before filing, with most sources putting the figure at $4,000 for an applicant with dependents. The visa lasts one year and can be renewed for a second. Health insurance of at least $50,000 per person is required, and holding the visa does not automatically open a path to permanent residence. Published guidance says Costa Rica does not tax foreign-sourced income for visa holders, but home-country tax rules still apply.
Colombia ties its threshold to the minimum wage. The 2026 minimum wage is COP 1,750,905, so the bar is COP 5,252,715 a month, shown over the previous three months. The visa runs for up to two years, income must come from abroad, and the time does not count toward permanent residency. Because the threshold is set in pesos and the consulate converts foreign income at the exchange rate on the day the file opens, guides recommend leaving a buffer.
Brazil's VITEM XIV visa offers the cleanest dual route: $1,500 a month in foreign income, or $18,000 in bank funds. It covers remote work for employers or clients outside Brazil, usually for one year with one renewal, though sources differ on whether the total can reach two years. One guide warns that Brazilian tax residency can attach after 183 days in any 12-month period.
Across all three, the common thread is that the permit covers foreign-sourced work only. A nomad in Medellín cannot take a Colombian client without switching visa categories.
Southeast Asia: Thailand, Malaysia, and Indonesia
Thailand's Destination Thailand Visa is aimed at remote workers, "soft power" activities such as Muay Thai training, cooking courses, and medical treatment, and the spouses and children of holders. According to the Thai embassy in Budapest, the visa is valid for five years, allows stays of up to 180 days per entry, and requires at least 500,000 baht in financial assets shown by a six-month official bank statement, payslips, or a sponsorship letter. Crypto and other investment statements are not accepted. Fees vary by consulate; the Budapest page lists 350 euro for multiple entry.
The DTV explicitly bars holders from obtaining a Thai work permit and from working for Thai companies or doing freelance work for Thai clients. Malaysia's DE Rantau Nomad Pass splits applicants into two groups. Per a September 2026 summary of the MDEC FAQ version 10.0 (dated August 28, 2026), tech and digital professionals need $24,000 a year, while non-tech professionals need $60,000. The pass is issued for 3 to 12 months and can be renewed for up to another 12, for a maximum of 24 months. The processing fee for a main applicant is RM1,080 including 8% sales and service tax, with RM540 per dependant.
The $24,000 figure that circulates widely applies only to the tech track, and some aggregator sites list different non-tech numbers, so applicants should check MDEC's live FAQ.
Indonesia's E33G Remote Worker KITAS asks for $60,000 in annual foreign-source income and an employment contract with a company registered outside Indonesia. The permit runs for one year, and sources conflict on extensions and on tax. One explainer says holding any KITAS, including the E33G, can make a person an Indonesian tax resident regardless of days spent in the country, which is a point to settle with an adviser before applying.
The clearest takeaway from the region is that "low cost of living" and "low visa barrier" are separate things. Thailand's bar is a lump sum, Malaysia's is an annual income test that doubles for non-tech workers, and Indonesia's is the highest of the three.
The Gulf and the Caribbean: no income tax, higher entry bars
The UAE's Dubai Virtual Working Programme requires proof of $5,000 a month, according to the UAE government portal's published criteria. Employees show a one-year employment contract and recent pay slips, while company owners show a year of ownership and average income at the same level. The programme fee is reported at $287 per person, plus insurance and processing fees, and the permit lasts one year. The UAE has no personal income tax on employment income, which is the main attraction, though the climate limits outdoor life for part of the year.
Barbados's Welcome Stamp asks for annual income of at least $50,000 and offers a stay of up to 12 months. The official page lists fees of $2,000 for an individual and $3,000 for a family bundle, and says visitors can reapply after the stay. Anyone planning a longer stay should check the program's current status first.
Both programs sell the same thing, which is a tax-light jurisdiction with an English-speaking environment. Neither leads to permanent residency, and both are priced for established professionals.
What nomad visas do not give you
A digital nomad visa is a narrow permit, and the limits are the part most easily missed.
Home-country taxes. A visa does not end tax obligations elsewhere. The United States taxes citizens on worldwide income regardless of where they live, and the foreign earned income exclusion for 2026 is $132,900 per qualifying person, according to the IRS inflation adjustments summarized by EY and KPMG. The exclusion has its own conditions, including a tax-home test and either bona fide residence or 330 days of physical presence in a 12-month period. Most European countries tax on residence, so becoming a tax resident of Portugal, Spain, or Estonia can end residence-based tax elsewhere, but treaty details vary. Anyone moving countries should consult a cross-border tax specialist. For a sense of how widely rates differ, see the rankings of countries with the lowest tax rates and countries with the highest income tax rates.
Tax residency days. Many countries treat more than 183 days of presence in a year as the trigger for tax residency. Some, including Portugal and Germany, have broader definitions that can apply with fewer days if you keep a permanent home there. A visa that lets you stay 180 days per entry, as Thailand's DTV does, can still create tax residency questions.
Local clients. Nearly every program restricts work to employers or clients outside the host country. Thailand, Colombia, Brazil, and Spain's freelancer rule all say so in different words. Working for a local client generally requires a standard work visa and local tax registration.
A path to settlement. Some permits count toward long-term residency, such as Spain's after five years, while others, including Costa Rica's, Colombia's, and Estonia's, do not. If settlement is the goal, check that before choosing a program.
Family coverage. Many programs include a spouse and dependent children, but the formulas differ. Portugal adds 50% and 30% to the income test, Greece reportedly adds 20% and 15%, and Colombia and Brazil require separate dependent applications.
Why some programs thrive and others stall
Programs tend to do well when the income test, the cost of living, and the paperwork line up. Spain tops the 2026 index, and it pairs the lowest monthly figure among the three big EU programs in this comparison with residence that can extend to five years. Thailand's DTV is built around a savings test that suits freelancers, and its five-year validity cuts the cost of repeat applications.
Programs stall on clarity. Indonesia's remote-worker permit illustrates it: sources disagree on extensions and on tax treatment, which makes it harder to plan. Estonia's conflicting official figures show a milder version of the same problem.
Cost of living adds another layer. A visa's income test and a city's price level are independent. Lisbon, Bangkok, and Medellín have very different monthly costs, and the same visa income can be a comfortable margin in one and a squeeze in another.
Safety, connectivity, and community also vary, and none of them appears on a visa form. Applicants in security-sensitive roles may weigh national cybersecurity capability, and those who value free time may weigh work-hour norms. Both are covered in the Related Reading list at the end.
Which visa fits which situation
| If you are... | Programs worth comparing | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A freelancer with uneven income | Thailand DTV, Brazil VITEM XIV | Both accept a savings or funds test instead of steady monthly income |
| A mid-income remote employee | Spain, Croatia, Colombia | Thresholds between roughly €2,850 and €3,650, or COP 5.25 million |
| A high earner seeking low income tax | UAE, Barbados | No personal income tax, but $5,000/month or $50,000/year to qualify |
| A tech professional in Asia | Malaysia DE Rantau | $24,000/year bar on the tech track |
| Someone seeking long-term EU residence | Spain, Portugal | Renewals build toward residence over five years |
| A family of four | Portugal, Greece, Croatia | Published add-ons for spouse and children, with higher totals |
The table is a starting point and not advice. A person's citizenship, existing tax status, and employer rules can change the answer.
Passport strength also shapes the choice, since it affects visa-free travel while an application is pending, and the passport ranking in the Related Reading list shows how much that varies by nationality.
Frequently asked questions
Q: Do digital nomads pay taxes in their home country while on a nomad visa? A: It depends on the home country. The United States taxes citizens on worldwide income, and the 2026 foreign earned income exclusion is $132,900 per qualifying person, subject to residence or physical-presence tests. Most European countries tax residents, so establishing tax residency abroad can end residency at home, though treaty rules vary. A cross-border tax specialist should confirm the position.
Q: How long can you stay before becoming a tax resident? A: Many countries use a threshold near 183 days in a year, but the rule is not universal. Some countries apply broader tests, such as having a permanent home available, and visa terms do not override tax law. A stay of 180 days on a Thai DTV entry, for example, is separate from the question of tax residency.
Q: Which digital nomad visa is easiest to get? A: By stated thresholds, Brazil ($1,500 a month or $18,000 in funds), Spain (about €2,849 a month), and Malaysia's tech track ($24,000 a year) are among the lower bars. Thailand's DTV substitutes a 500,000 baht funds test for an income test. Easiest on paper is not the same as easiest in practice, because document rules, processing times, and consular practice vary.
Q: Can I work for local clients on a nomad visa? A: Usually not. The Thai DTV bars work for Thai companies and freelance work for Thai clients, Colombia and Brazil require foreign-sourced work, and Spain caps Spanish-client income for freelancers at 20%. Working locally generally requires a different visa and local tax registration.
Q: Does a nomad visa lead to permanent residency or citizenship? A: Rarely, and it varies. Spain's permit can build toward long-term residency after five years of legal residence. Costa Rica's and Colombia's visas do not automatically lead to permanent residence, and Estonia's does not lead directly to it. Citizenship rules are separate and depend on each country's law.
Q: Which nomad visa is best for families? A: Portugal's D8 and Spain's visa both cover spouses and children, with higher income thresholds. Greece, Croatia, and Thailand's DTV also cover family members under their own formulas. Colombia and Brazil require a separate application for each dependent. Schools, healthcare access, and the cost of the family add-on should be compared before choosing.
Q: Why do different websites give different income figures for the same visa? A: Many thresholds are tied to the minimum wage or average salary and reset each year, so older articles go stale. Sources also disagree on gross versus net, on family add-ons, and on exchange rates. When figures conflict, the official government or consulate page controls.
The takeaway
The nomad-visa market has moved from novelty to a crowded field of programs that quietly raise their bars as demand grows. Estonia's 2026 threshold of €4,500 a month is about 28% above the €3,504 reported in older guides, Portugal's rose with its minimum wage, and Spain's changed with its own. The programs that look generous often attach limits on local clients, tax treatment, or the path to residency, and those limits decide the real value more than the headline number does. Before picking a country, check the formula, the measurement window, the gross-or-net basis, and the tax rules at home, in that order.
Sources
- Remote Work Europe, Digital Nomad Visa Index 2026, for the country counts, the EY figure, and the Estonia, Portugal, and Spain monthly thresholds.
- Remote Work Europe, Portugal D8 income threshold 2026, March 31, 2026.
- Remote Work Europe, Spain Digital Nomad Visa 2026, citing Royal Decree 126/2026 and Ley 28/2022.
- Jobbatical, Estonia digital nomad visa income requirement and quota.
- Royal Thai Embassy, Budapest, Destination Thailand Visa (DTV).
- Digitalnomads.world, Malaysia DE Rantau eligibility update, September 19, 2026, summarizing the MDEC FAQ version 10.0.
Figures for Greece, Croatia, Italy, Costa Rica, Colombia, Brazil, Indonesia, the UAE, and Barbados come from 2026 immigration-research and government-portal summaries and should be checked against each country's official immigration page before any application.
Related Reading
Follow new articles
Add SciHub101 to your feed reader to see new science and technology stories.
About the Author
SciHub101 is an independent science and technology publication founded and edited by Buğra Sözeri, a software engineer and app developer based in Türkiye. AI tools assist with drafting and research. Source documentation in the existing archive is uneven, and articles are being reviewed and corrected. The Editorial Team byline identifies editorial responsibility; it does not certify specialist or independent human review. Where we compare products, anything built by our own team is labelled as such — see the editorial guidelines and About page for how corrections and disclosures work.
Related Articles

Countries With the Best Pension Systems (2025)
The Netherlands, Iceland, and Denmark top the 2025 Mercer CFA Institute Global Pension Index, with Singapore and Israel also earning an A. The pattern behind the scores: large funded savings, strong governance, and a retirement age that moves with life expectancy.

Countries That Produce the Most Wine in the World (2025 Ranked)
Italy, France, and Spain produce nearly half of all the world's wine. Global production reached 258 million hectolitres in 2023. China is now the world's fifth-largest wine producer. Here's who makes the most wine, how climate change is reshaping the wine map, and which new regions are rising.

Countries Most Dependent on Tourism: Data Ranked
World Bank data show Aruba and the Maldives earning tourism receipts equal to more than half of GDP in 2019. This ranking compares a dozen economies, explains why small islands are most exposed, and shows what the 2020 collapse in travel did to each.

Most Powerful Passports in the World (2026)
Singapore holds the world's most powerful passport in the July 2026 Henley Passport Index, with access to 192 destinations without a prior visa. Here is how the Henley and Arton indexes rank passports — and why they disagree.

Countries with the Most Tourist Arrivals (Ranked)
France received more international tourists than any other country in 2024 — approximately 102 million arrivals, making it the first country in history to surpass the 100 million annual mark. Spain ranked second with 93.8 million, the United States third with 72.4 million. Turkey and Italy round out the top five. But raw arrival numbers obscure important distinctions: the United States earns more tourism revenue than any other country despite ranking third in arrivals. This ranking covers the top 20 countries by international tourist arrivals using UN Tourism (UNWTO) 2024 data, with methodology, historical context, and revenue analysis.

Countries Investing the Most in AI: 2026 Rankings
The US leads global AI investment by a massive margin, but Saudi Arabia and UAE are now committing percentages of GDP that rival Silicon Valley.