Watson and Crick: The Double Helix, Photo 51, and the Most Consequential Discovery in Biology

Photo: Daria / Pexels
James Watson (born 1928) and Francis Crick (1916–2004) published the structure of DNA — the double helix — in a nine-hundred-word paper in Nature on April 25, 1953. The paper proposed a model built from cardboard and wire, confirmed by X-ray crystallography data they had not gathered themselves, and announced with a sentence that is among the most understated in the history of science: "It has not escaped our notice that the specific pairing we have postulated immediately suggests a possible copying mechanism for the genetic material." The copying mechanism is the basis of all molecular biology, genetic engineering, and genomic medicine since. The discovery is routinely called the most important in twentieth-century biology. Its full story — including the role of Rosalind Franklin, whose X-ray photograph of DNA was shown to Watson without her knowledge, and the later trajectories of Watson and Crick — is considerably more complicated than the triumphant account that first circulated, and understanding it properly requires holding the science and the ethics in the same frame.
Quick Biography
Francis Crick was born on June 8, 1916, in Northampton, England. He studied physics at University College London, completing his bachelor's degree in 1937. The war interrupted his research; he spent the conflict working on magnetic mines for the British Admiralty. He came to the Medical Research Council's Unit for the Study of the Molecular Structure of Biological Systems in Cambridge in 1947, working toward a PhD in structural biology. He was thirty-five in 1951 when James Watson arrived in Cambridge and they began their collaboration on DNA. He completed his PhD in 1954, the year after the DNA paper was published.
Crick continued at Cambridge's MRC Laboratory of Molecular Biology, making foundational contributions to the genetic code (what he called the Central Dogma — DNA transcribes to RNA, RNA translates to protein) and to the adaptor hypothesis (the prediction that transfer RNA would serve as the adaptor between nucleotide sequence and amino acid sequence, confirmed experimentally in 1958). He moved to the Salk Institute in La Jolla, California in 1977, where he worked on the theoretical neuroscience of consciousness until his death from colon cancer on July 28, 2004.
James Watson was born on April 6, 1928, in Chicago, Illinois. He was a child prodigy who entered the University of Chicago at fifteen, receiving his bachelor's degree in zoology in 1947 at nineteen. He completed his PhD at Indiana University in 1950 under the geneticist Salvador Luria, studying the effects of X-rays on bacteriophage (bacterial viruses). He arrived at the Cavendish Laboratory in Cambridge in 1951 on a fellowship to work on the structure of proteins, and encountered Crick.
After the DNA work, Watson moved to Harvard, where he became a professor, eventually directing the Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory in New York from 1968. He led the Human Genome Project from 1988 to 1992, when he resigned following a dispute over the patenting of gene sequences. He published his personal account of the DNA discovery, The Double Helix, in 1968. He received honorary degrees and lectureships throughout his career. His later years were marked by public controversies over racist statements, which cost him his institutional positions and led him to sell his Nobel medal.
Personal Lives: Two Very Different Men Outside the Lab
The private lives of Watson and Crick diverged as sharply as their later careers. Crick married twice. His first marriage, to Ruth Doreen Dodd in 1940, produced a son, Michael, before ending in divorce. In 1949, he married Odile Speed, a French-born artist, with whom he had two daughters, Gabrielle and Jacqueline. The marriage to Odile lasted until his death in 2004. Odile Crick was not a scientific collaborator in any formal sense, but she contributed to the DNA discovery in one concrete way: the double helix illustration that appeared in the 1953 Nature paper — the famous figure of two intertwined chains with paired bases — was drawn by Odile. The illustration that introduced the double helix to the world was the work of the scientist's wife, a trained artist who understood what he was describing and could render it clearly. Her contribution was credited in the paper.
Crick's intellectual interests in his final decades at the Salk Institute were centered on consciousness. His 1994 book The Astonishing Hypothesis: The Scientific Search for the Soul argued that consciousness is entirely explicable by the activity of neurons — that "you," your experiences, memories, and sense of self, are nothing more than the behavior of a vast assembly of nerve cells. This was a deliberate provocation: Crick took the title phrase from the public discourse in which the idea that the soul might be reducible to biology was considered startling. His working approach was to focus on visual consciousness as the most tractable entry point, and he collaborated extensively with the neuroscientist Christof Koch on the neural correlates of visual awareness. The work he did in his final years was genuinely original science, not a senior scientist trading on a famous name.
Watson married Elizabeth Lewis in 1968 — the same year he published The Double Helix. They have two sons, Rufus and Duncan. Watson's public persona through the 1970s, 1980s, and 1990s was that of a blunt, often combative scientist-administrator who was willing to say things in public that most scientists thought privately and did not say. This quality served him reasonably well as a fundraiser and institution-builder at Cold Spring Harbor, and disastrously in 2007.
Major Scientific Contributions
The Double Helix Structure of DNA
The structure of DNA — what it is, physically — was the central unsolved problem of molecular biology in the early 1950s. It was known, from Oswald Avery's 1944 experiments, that DNA was the genetic material. It was known, from Erwin Chargaff's measurements, that in any DNA sample the amount of adenine equaled the amount of thymine, and the amount of guanine equaled the amount of cytosine (Chargaff's rules). It was known, from X-ray crystallography work at King's College London, that DNA produced characteristic diffraction patterns suggesting a helical structure. What was not known was how all of this fit together.
Watson and Crick's approach was model-building: they assembled physical models of the molecule from machined metal plates, wire, and cardboard, testing whether proposed configurations were sterically possible — whether the bonds had correct angles and lengths — and whether they fit the known physical data. Two earlier attempts at models had failed: Linus Pauling's triple helix model (proposed in early 1953) had the phosphate backbone inside and the bases outside, which was chemically implausible, and a Watson-Crick double helix model from 1951 was wrong about where the bases sat.
The correct model, arrived at in February and March of 1953, had two polynucleotide chains wound around each other in a right-handed helix, with the sugar-phosphate backbone on the outside and the nitrogenous bases stacked inside and paired across the helix — adenine always paired with thymine, guanine always paired with cytosine. This was the key insight: the base pairing rules, combined with the helical geometry, meant that the sequence on one strand determined the sequence on the other. Each strand was the template for a new complementary strand. DNA could copy itself.
The significance extended beyond structure to function. The double helix immediately explained how genetic information could be stored (as a sequence of base pairs), copied (by unwinding and using each strand as a template), and transmitted to offspring. The entire apparatus of molecular genetics — PCR, gene sequencing, CRISPR, mRNA vaccines — is built on this structural foundation.
The Central Dogma and the Genetic Code
After the DNA structure, Crick made further foundational contributions. In 1958 he proposed the Central Dogma: genetic information flows from DNA to RNA to protein, and not in reverse. He also proposed the adaptor hypothesis: some kind of small RNA molecule must serve as an adaptor, pairing with messenger RNA codons on one end and carrying the corresponding amino acid on the other — what became known as transfer RNA. Both predictions were experimentally confirmed.
Crick was also a central figure in the collaborative work that cracked the genetic code — establishing which three-base codons in RNA correspond to which amino acids. The code was fully worked out by 1966.
Watson and the Human Genome Project
Watson's contribution to molecular biology did not end with the double helix. In 1988, he was appointed to lead the newly established Office of Human Genome Research at the National Institutes of Health, which became the National Center for Human Genome Research — the agency charged with coordinating the U.S. component of the Human Genome Project. The Project aimed to sequence the entire human genome: all three billion base pairs of DNA in the human cell nucleus.
Watson's role was not to do the sequencing himself but to build the institutional and political framework that made the science possible: securing funding, establishing international collaboration, and setting the research agenda. He was an effective advocate, using his Nobel Prize credibility and his combative self-confidence to push the project forward at a time when many biologists were skeptical that large-scale sequencing was the right use of resources.
He resigned in 1992 following a dispute with NIH director Bernadine Healy over the patenting of gene sequences. Watson opposed the policy of filing patents on human gene sequences — arguing that genes were natural discoveries that should be freely available to all researchers — while NIH was pursuing a strategy of filing provisional patents to protect American commercial interests. The conflict escalated to the point where Watson's position became untenable, and he resigned. The policy question he raised — whether genes can and should be patented — remained contested throughout the completion of the Human Genome Project and into the present day.
The Human Genome Project completed a working draft in 2000 and a finished sequence in 2003. Watson's contribution to making it happen, through four years of institution-building in the critical early phase, is documented in histories of the project even where his later controversies are also noted.
Quirks
Photo 51 and the Ethics of Discovery
The most significant and contested aspect of the Watson-Crick story is what happened with Photograph 51. This was an X-ray diffraction image of the B form of DNA, taken by Rosalind Franklin and her student Raymond Gosling in May 1952. It was, technically, one of the best X-ray diffraction photographs of DNA ever obtained, and it was immediately interpretable by a trained crystallographer as showing a helical structure with specific parameters.
In January 1953, Watson visited King's College London to meet with Maurice Wilkins. Wilkins showed Watson Franklin's Photo 51 — without Franklin's knowledge and without her consent — because Wilkins had gained access to it when Franklin's supervisor Max Perutz shared Franklin's data with the MRC committee, and this data had been circulated to Watson and Crick through channels Franklin was unaware of. Watson later described the moment in The Double Helix: "The instant I saw the picture my mouth fell open and my pulse began to race." He recorded the key measurements in his mind — the dimensions of the unit cell, the helical repeat — and used them to build the correct model.
The ethical question is not a minor footnote. Franklin's Photo 51 gave Watson the critical parameters he needed. His account of the moment makes clear that it was decisive. The 1968 memoir The Double Helix also portrayed Franklin, under the name "Rosy" — a diminutive she disliked — as difficult, unfeminine, and subordinate to Wilkins; the portrayal was widely criticized, including by Franklin's friends and colleagues, as both inaccurate and demeaning.
Did Watson and Crick commit scientific misconduct? The question is analyzed carefully in the historical literature. The data were shared through channels that were, at the time, institutionally permitted — the MRC committee report was shared among MRC units including Cavendish. Watson and Crick did not misrepresent their sources in the paper — the 1953 Nature paper is accompanied by companion papers from Wilkins, Stokes, and Wilson and from Franklin and Gosling, acknowledging the King's College X-ray work. But the companion papers did not fully disclose that Franklin's specific measurements had been shared with Watson and Crick and had been critical to their model. Franklin died of ovarian cancer in 1958, four years before the 1962 Nobel Prize was awarded to Watson, Crick, and Wilkins; the Nobel Committee's rules precluded posthumous awards, and Franklin's contribution was not recognized in the prize.
The contemporary consensus among historians of science is that Franklin's contribution was essential, that the sharing of her data without her knowledge was ethically questionable by any reasonable standard, and that the attribution she received during her lifetime was inadequate.
"The Secret of Life" at The Eagle
On the day Watson and Crick determined the correct structure — February 28, 1953, according to the most commonly cited reconstruction — Crick reportedly walked into The Eagle pub in Cambridge, where they often lunched, and announced that they had found "the secret of life." This is one of the most quoted announcements in the history of science, and it has been verified in its broad outlines: multiple people who were present confirmed in later interviews that Crick made an announcement of this kind. Watson's account in The Double Helix says "Francis winged into The Eagle to tell everyone within hearing distance that we had found the secret of life."
Whether Crick used the exact phrase "secret of life" is uncertain — Watson's memory and the exact phrasing are not independently corroborated in the same terms. The essential fact — that Crick announced the discovery loudly in the pub — is well attested. The Eagle pub subsequently placed a commemorative plaque, which has made the location part of Cambridge's scientific heritage circuit.
Crick's Consciousness Turn and "The Astonishing Hypothesis"
Crick's move to the Salk Institute in 1977 marked a deliberate pivot from molecular biology to the problem of consciousness. He had, by his own account, said everything he had to say about DNA and the genetic code; the field he helped create had grown large enough to carry itself forward without him. Consciousness was different — it remained genuinely unsolved, and Crick believed that applying the same reductionist tools that had worked for molecular biology could make progress there too.
His 1994 book The Astonishing Hypothesis was addressed to a general audience but grounded in real neuroscience. Crick argued that the seat of visual consciousness in the brain was most likely in a brain region called area V4 and in the interactions between cortical areas — a specific, testable claim. His collaboration with Christof Koch produced influential papers on the neural correlates of consciousness that defined the field's research agenda through the 1990s and 2000s. Koch later wrote that Crick approached consciousness with the same intensity he had brought to DNA: reading widely, asking the simplest possible questions, refusing to be impressed by complexity for its own sake.
The contrast with Penrose is instructive. In the same year — 1994 — Crick published The Astonishing Hypothesis, arguing that consciousness is fully explicable by neural activity, and Penrose published Shadows of the Mind, arguing that consciousness requires quantum computation beyond what any classical neural process can provide. Both were serious scientists applying their expertise to the hardest problem in science. They reached opposite conclusions. Neither has been decisively proved right or wrong.
Watson's Later Racist Statements and Consequences
In 2007, James Watson gave an interview to the Sunday Times of London in which he made statements claiming that Africans had lower intelligence than Europeans. He said he was "inherently gloomy about the prospect of Africa" because "all our social policies are based on the fact that their intelligence is the same as ours — whereas all the testing says not really." He also stated he hoped everyone was equal but that "people who have to deal with black employees find this not true."
The scientific premise of the statements — that intelligence tests reveal heritable racial differences in cognitive capacity — is not supported by the genetic and cognitive scientific literature. The claim misrepresents both what intelligence tests measure and what population genetics reveals about human cognitive variation. Leading geneticists and cognitive scientists responded publicly and directly; the Science Museum in London cancelled a planned talk; Watson was stripped of three honorary titles at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, where he had worked for nearly forty years. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory issued a statement that the views were "reprehensible" and were "not the views of CSHL, its trustees, faculty, staff, or students."
Watson sold his Nobel Prize medal in 2014, reportedly because of the financial consequences of the controversy — including losing paid speaking engagements — which had left him, by his account, with limited income. It sold at auction for $4.1 million. The buyer, the Russian fertilizer billionaire Alisher Usmanov, subsequently returned the medal to Watson.
In 2019, a PBS documentary aired in which Watson maintained and extended his earlier positions on race and intelligence. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory revoked his honorary titles permanently and terminated his remaining honorary positions. These consequences are documented. Watson's scientific contribution remains what it was; the structure of DNA is not undiscovered by his later statements, and his role in working it out is not erased. The consequences serve as a reminder that scientific achievement and moral accountability are not in the same category and do not offset each other.
Crick's LSD Claim — What the Record Actually Says
There is a widely repeated claim that Francis Crick told friends he had taken LSD before working out the DNA structure and that the drug had contributed to the insight. This story gained wide circulation after an article by Alun Rees in the Mail on Sunday in 2004, following Crick's death. Rees attributed the claim to Crick's friend Gerhard Gruber.
The claim is not supported by any direct statement from Crick himself. LSD was not synthesized until 1938 and was not available in Cambridge in 1953 in any documented form. The DNA structure was worked out in early 1953; the association of LSD with intellectual creativity in scientific culture did not develop until the mid-1960s in the United States, over a decade later. Crick was known to be interested in consciousness and neuroscience in his later career at the Salk Institute — which may have involved interest in psychedelic research, though this is also not documented — but the specific claim that he used LSD while working on the DNA structure was reported secondhand, after his death, and cannot be confirmed from his own writing or from contemporaries who were present. The claim is best described as unverified.
Famous Quotes
Francis Crick: "If you want to understand function, study structure." (Cited widely in molecular biology — attributed in multiple accounts to Crick's working philosophy)
Francis Crick: "The central dogma, this is the key to molecular biology." (On the Genetic Code, MRC lectures, 1958)
James Watson: "Every great discovery I ever made, I gambled that the truth was there, and then I acted on it in faith until it could be proved." (The Double Helix, 1968)
James Watson: "It has not escaped our notice that the specific pairing we have postulated immediately suggests a possible copying mechanism for the genetic material." (Watson and Crick, Nature, April 25, 1953 — the most consequentially understated sentence in biology)
Francis Crick: "We have discovered the secret of life." (Reported by Watson; announced at The Eagle pub, February 1953)
Legacy
The double helix structure of DNA is the foundation on which all of molecular biology, genetic engineering, and genomic medicine rests. Every subsequent development in the field — gene cloning, DNA sequencing, PCR, the Human Genome Project, gene therapy, mRNA vaccines for COVID-19, CRISPR gene editing — depends on the understanding of how DNA stores, copies, and expresses genetic information that the double helix model made possible. The scale of this dependence is difficult to overstate.
Watson and Crick's 1953 paper is among the most consequential publications in the history of science. It is also a document whose full context — including Franklin's contribution, the access to her data, and the ethics of how the discovery was assembled — is essential to understanding how the science actually happened. The science and the history are both important, and neither can be reduced to the other.
For the contribution of Rosalind Franklin in particular, the record has been significantly revised since the early accounts. Her crystallographic work, and Photo 51 specifically, was the observational evidence that made the correct model possible. Her story is now taught alongside Watson and Crick's in most accounts of the discovery, and the injustice of her exclusion from the Nobel Prize is acknowledged widely in the scientific community.
Q: What did Watson and Crick discover?
A: Watson and Crick determined the three-dimensional structure of DNA in 1953: two polynucleotide chains wound in a right-handed double helix, with complementary base pairs (adenine-thymine, guanine-cytosine) running along the inside of the helix. This structure immediately explained how genetic information is stored (base sequence) and copied (each strand serves as a template for a new complementary strand), and became the foundation of all subsequent molecular biology.
Q: What was Photo 51 and why does it matter?
A: Photo 51 was an X-ray diffraction image of DNA taken by Rosalind Franklin and Raymond Gosling in May 1952. It was the clearest image of DNA's helical structure then obtained and contained key measurements (helical repeat, unit cell dimensions) that Watson used to build the correct model after seeing the photo without Franklin's knowledge. Franklin's contribution was not acknowledged in the 1962 Nobel Prize; she had died in 1958 and Nobel Prizes are not awarded posthumously.
Q: Did Watson and Crick steal Rosalind Franklin's data?
A: Watson saw Photo 51 when Wilkins showed it to him without Franklin's knowledge or consent. The MRC committee data including Franklin's measurements had been shared with Watson and Crick through institutional channels that were technically permitted at the time but ethically questionable by contemporary research ethics standards. The historical consensus is that Franklin's data was essential to the correct model and that her contribution was not adequately credited during her lifetime.
Q: What happened to James Watson after the 2007 race controversy?
A: Watson made statements in a 2007 Sunday Times interview claiming that Africans had lower intelligence than Europeans. He was stripped of honorary titles at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, lost speaking engagements, and sold his Nobel medal in 2014. A 2019 PBS documentary in which he maintained his positions led Cold Spring Harbor to permanently revoke all his remaining honorary positions. The scientific community broadly rejected his claims as unsupported by genetics and cognitive science.
Q: Did Francis Crick use LSD when working on DNA?
A: This claim is not supported by any direct statement from Crick himself and was reported posthumously, primarily through secondhand accounts. LSD was not in common circulation in Cambridge in 1953 when the DNA structure was worked out. The claim originated in a 2004 article in the Mail on Sunday, published after Crick's death, attributed to a friend. It cannot be confirmed and is best characterized as unverified.
Q: What was Watson's role in the Human Genome Project?
A: Watson led the U.S. effort from 1988 to 1992, building the institutional and funding structures that launched the project. He opposed the NIH's policy of filing patents on gene sequences — arguing genes should be freely available to all researchers — and resigned when that dispute became irresolvable. The project he helped establish was completed in 2003. His early leadership during the critical organizational phase is acknowledged in histories of the project alongside his later controversies.
Q: What did Francis Crick work on after DNA?
A: After the DNA and genetic code work in the 1950s and 1960s, Crick moved to the Salk Institute in 1977 and devoted his final decades to the neuroscience of consciousness. His 1994 book The Astonishing Hypothesis argued that consciousness is fully reducible to neural activity. He collaborated with neuroscientist Christof Koch on identifying the neural correlates of visual awareness — specific brain states that accompany conscious perception. He continued this research until shortly before his death from colon cancer in 2004.
Q: Who drew the famous double helix illustration in the 1953 Nature paper?
A: The double helix diagram that appeared in the original 1953 Nature paper — showing two intertwined chains with paired bases — was drawn by Odile Crick, Francis Crick's wife, who was a trained artist. Her contribution was credited in the paper. The illustration, which introduced the double helix to the scientific world, was the work of an artist who understood what her husband had described and could render it visually.
Sources
- Watson, J.D., and F.H.C. Crick. "A Structure for Deoxyribose Nucleic Acid." Nature 171 (1953): 737–738.
- Franklin, R.E., and R.G. Gosling. "Molecular Configuration in Sodium Thymonucleate." Nature 171 (1953): 740–741. (Companion paper)
- Watson, James D. The Double Helix: A Personal Account of the Discovery of the Structure of DNA. Atheneum, 1968.
- Crick, Francis. The Astonishing Hypothesis: The Scientific Search for the Soul. Scribner, 1994.
- Maddox, Brenda. Rosalind Franklin: The Dark Lady of DNA. HarperCollins, 2002.
- Judson, Horace Freeland. The Eighth Day of Creation: Makers of the Revolution in Biology. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, 1996.
- Olby, Robert. The Path to the Double Helix: The Discovery of DNA. University of Washington Press, 1974.
- Cobb, Matthew. Life's Greatest Secret: The Race to Crack the Genetic Code. Basic Books, 2015.
- Cook-Deegan, Robert. The Gene Wars: Science, Politics, and the Human Genome. W.W. Norton, 1994. (On Watson's role in the Human Genome Project)
Follow new articles
Add SciHub101 to your feed reader to see new science and technology stories.
About the Author
SciHub101 is an independent science and technology publication founded and edited by Buğra Sözeri, a software engineer and app developer based in Türkiye. AI tools assist with drafting and research. Source documentation in the existing archive is uneven, and articles are being reviewed and corrected. The Editorial Team byline identifies editorial responsibility; it does not certify specialist or independent human review. Where we compare products, anything built by our own team is labelled as such — see the editorial guidelines and About page for how corrections and disclosures work.
Related Articles

Donna Strickland: Third Woman to Win Physics Nobel, Still an Associate Professor When She Won
Donna Strickland's chirped pulse amplification technique is the laser physics behind LASIK eye surgery. Wikipedia rejected her as 'not notable' five months before her 2018 Nobel Prize.

Wolfgang Pauli: The Exclusion Principle and the Neutrino
Wolfgang Pauli formulated the exclusion principle in 1925 and predicted the neutrino in 1930. Explore his physics, sharp wit, and legendary Pauli effect.

Rosalind Franklin: Photo 51 and the Discovery That Was Stolen in Plain Sight
Rosalind Franklin's life, discoveries, and verified quirks: Photo 51, refusal to marry, death at 37, and how her X-ray crystallography work was used without her knowledge.

Linus Pauling: Two Nobel Prizes, the Wrong DNA Model, and the Vitamin C Obsession
Linus Pauling won two unshared Nobel Prizes, proposed the wrong triple-helix DNA structure, and spent decades promoting vitamin C megadoses that science has not validated.

The Avery-MacLeod-McCarty Experiment: DNA Is the Transforming Principle
In 1944, Avery, MacLeod, and McCarty proved DNA carries hereditary information by identifying it as Griffith's transforming principle. The experiment that made the DNA era possible.

The Hershey-Chase Experiment: The Blender That Settled the DNA Debate
In 1952, Alfred Hershey and Martha Chase used radioactive isotopes and a kitchen blender to prove DNA is the genetic material. Here's how the experiment worked.