Spallanzani's Sealed-Broth Experiments
For thousands of years, people believed life could spring spontaneously from non-living matter: maggots from rotting meat, mice from grain stores, frogs from mud. In the 17th century, this belief shifted slightly—to the idea that microscopic creatures, newly visible through early microscopes, could be generated spontaneously inside liquids. Then Italian naturalist Lazzaro Spallanzani, in a book published in 1765, described a series of elegantly simple experiments with sealed glass flasks and infusions. By boiling the flasks for a long time, sealing them airtight, and observing what did and did not grow inside, Spallanzani provided strong experimental evidence that microorganisms do not arise spontaneously in a heated infusion, but come from outside. His work didn't end the spontaneous generation debate, but it shifted the burden of proof.
The spontaneous generation debate in the 18th century
Spontaneous generation — the hypothesis that life could arise directly from non-living matter, without a living parent — was ancient doctrine. Most educated people in the early modern period believed it. Fish emerged from mud, insects from organic material, and (under the microscope) tiny creatures from infusions of seeds, hay, or meat.
In 1668, Francesco Redi had already challenged part of this with an elegant experiment: he put meat in jars, left some open to flies and others covered with cloth, and found maggots only in the open jars. This suggested that maggots did not arise spontaneously in meat but came from fly eggs. Redi's work seemed to narrow the domain of spontaneous generation, but it didn't end the idea that microscopically small creatures could arise spontaneously in broths and infusions.
By the 18th century, microscopy had improved, and naturalists could see that liquids—especially infusions of organic matter (broth made from meat, water in which hay had been soaked, etc.)—filled rapidly with tiny moving creatures. The question was: where did these creatures come from? Did they arise spontaneously in the liquid, or were they introduced from the air?
John Turberville Needham, an English Catholic priest and naturalist, reported experiments in 1748 in which he heated mutton gravy and other vegetable and animal infusions in vials closed with corks. He still found microorganisms in the liquids afterward. Needham concluded that organic matter contains a "vegetative force" that can generate living things without parents, and that the microbes he saw arose spontaneously.
Spallanzani's challenge
Lazzaro Spallanzani, an Italian polymath naturalist and priest, was skeptical of Needham's conclusion. He suspected that Needham's sealing procedure might not have been truly airtight, or that heating hadn't been vigorous enough to destroy all pre-existing organisms.
Spallanzani repeated Needham's experiments with improvements. He filled glass flasks with infusions of seeds and other matter and sealed some of them by melting the glass of the neck shut in a flame, a hermetic seal far tighter than Needham's corks. He then immersed the flasks in boiling water for as long as an hour, far longer than Needham's brief heating. As controls, he left some flasks open to the air and closed others only loosely with corks.
The result, as historians summarize it, was clear: the open flasks swarmed with animalcules, the loosely corked ones had many fewer, and the hermetically sealed, boiled flasks contained none. The broth in the sealed flasks remained clear, without the turbidity that indicated microbial growth.
Spallanzani also reported that when he later broke open sealed flasks that had stayed clear, microorganisms appeared in the infusion once air had entered. The obvious inference was that the organisms came in with the air, not from the broth itself.
The "life force" objection and Spallanzani's response
Needham and his supporters raised an obvious objection: maybe vigorous boiling destroyed some "vital principle" or "life force" necessary for spontaneous generation to occur. By this logic, Spallanzani's heated sealed flasks didn't disprove spontaneous generation; they just showed that heat destroyed the material's capacity for it.
Spallanzani answered this in two ways. First, he argued that the broth itself was not ruined: when he broke open a long-boiled, sealed flask and let air in, microorganisms appeared afterward, so the heated infusion could still support life. Whatever heat had done, it had not destroyed the broth's capacity to feed organisms. Second, he compared seals directly. Flasks closed only with a cork or a loose stopper, as Needham's had been, developed some organisms even after boiling; flasks whose necks were melted shut stayed clear. The difference between the two groups was not the heat but the route by which air and the particles it carried could get in.
The point Spallanzani could not fully settle was Needham's claim about the air inside the flask. If heating a sealed flask altered the small volume of trapped air, critics could argue that it was the air, not the broth, that had lost its generative power. That gap is the one Louis Pasteur's swan-necked flasks closed in the early 1860s, nearly a century later, by letting unheated air reach the broth freely while dust stayed trapped in the bend of the neck.
Establishing biogenesis
Spallanzani's work supported the principle of biogenesis — the hypothesis that living organisms arise only from pre-existing living organisms, never from non-living matter. That principle became a cornerstone of modern biology.
However, even Spallanzani's meticulous work did not immediately end spontaneous generation belief. Skeptics argued that his heating might have destroyed some essential ingredient, or that the "vital principle" simply couldn't be revived in the presence of air. The debate persisted for another century.
It took Louis Pasteur's experiments in the 1860s, using swan-necked flasks that allowed air in but prevented dust and microbes from settling into the broth, to finally convince the scientific mainstream that spontaneous generation was false. Pasteur's work was more sophisticated and harder to dismiss, but Spallanzani's sealed flasks had already done much of the conceptual work: they showed that broth boiled for a long time and properly sealed does not give rise to new life. Pasteur evidently valued the earlier work; the Linda Hall Library notes that he later displayed a full-size portrait of Spallanzani in his workspace.
The practical consequences
Spallanzani's findings had obvious practical implications. If microorganisms came in from outside, then heating a liquid and excluding air could prevent spoilage. Boiling and sealing are the same two steps that underlie food preservation techniques that remain essential today, although, as discussed below, the link between his experiments and the first canners is not documented.
More profoundly, Spallanzani's experiments suggested that the microbial world was not one of spontaneous generation from corruption, but of a specific, living lineage. Every organism came from a parent. This framework eventually opened the door to understanding microbes as having evolutionary history, ecology, and disease-transmission capacity—ideas essential to modern microbiology and medicine.
Why the resistance persisted
The rejection of spontaneous generation came so slowly because the alternative—that microscopic creatures existed everywhere in the air and water, entering bodies and causing disease—was deeply unsettling. If that were true, then human disease was not a matter of individual constitution or miasma but of invasion by foreign agents. This required a different mental model of illness, treatment, and prevention.
Additionally, the experiments required careful technique and good glassware. Not every naturalist could replicate them perfectly. Contamination or technique errors could make results ambiguous. In an era before germ theory, before the understanding of specific disease-causing organisms, Spallanzani's sealed flasks could seem like an artificial setup that told little about the real world.
Who Lazzaro Spallanzani was
Lazzaro Spallanzani (1729–1799) was born in Scandiano, near Reggio Emilia in northern Italy. His father, a lawyer, sent him to Bologna to study law, but there he came under the influence of his relative Laura Bassi, one of the first women to hold a university chair in Europe, who taught physics and mathematics. Spallanzani turned to natural science, was ordained a priest, and held posts at Reggio and Modena before being appointed in 1768 to the chair of natural history at the University of Pavia, where he also directed the natural history museum.
He was an exceptionally wide-ranging experimenter. Beyond the broth work, he studied the regeneration of limbs and tails in salamanders, newts and snails; showed that digestion is a chemical process by having animals, and himself, swallow food in small perforated tubes and linen bags and then recovering them; performed artificial insemination in frogs and, in a famous case, a dog, which produced a litter of puppies; and investigated how bats navigate in total darkness, concluding that they relied on hearing rather than sight. That last finding was decades ahead of its time, and its explanation, echolocation, was confirmed only in the 1930s and 1940s by Donald Griffin and colleagues.
The two key publications
Spallanzani's attack on spontaneous generation came in two stages. The first was Saggio di osservazioni microscopiche concernenti il sistema della generazione dei signori di Needham e Buffon (1765), an essay of microscopic observations directed explicitly at Needham and the French naturalist Georges-Louis Leclerc, Comte de Buffon. The second, more detailed account appeared in Opuscoli di fisica animale e vegetabile (1776). Needham, for his part, had the 1765 essay translated into French in 1769 and added extensive notes of his own to rebut it.
The title of the 1765 essay matters. Spallanzani was not arguing against a vague popular belief but against a specific, sophisticated theory. Buffon and Needham held that living matter was made up of indestructible "organic molecules." When an organism died, these molecules were released and could recombine into new microscopic beings, driven by a "vegetative force." On that theory, microbes appearing in a boiled infusion were not contaminants but the natural reorganisation of organic matter. Needham's boiled, corked flasks were evidence for the theory. Spallanzani's task was to show that the evidence came from poor technique.
The hidden complication: heat-resistant spores
Why did some experimenters keep finding life in flasks that had been boiled? Part of the answer was not understood until the 1870s. In 1876 the German botanist Ferdinand Cohn described the heat-resistant spores of the hay bacillus (now Bacillus subtilis), dormant forms that survive boiling for long periods and then germinate. Around the same time, the physicist John Tyndall, investigating hay infusions in London, found that some of them could not be sterilised by ordinary boiling, and developed a method of repeated, intermittent heating, now called tyndallisation, which kills spores after they germinate. Experiments with hay infusion were especially likely to fail because hay carries spore-forming bacteria. Some of the later results of Pasteur's opponents, such as Pouchet's hay infusions, were real observations; the organisms simply came from heat-resistant spores, not from spontaneous generation.
Why Needham's flasks grew microbes
Seen from today, Needham's results probably came from several problems at once:
- Short heating. Spallanzani argued that Needham heated his gravy only briefly, which would kill many vegetative cells but might leave hardier forms.
- Imperfect seals. Needham closed his vials with cork, sometimes covered with mastic. Cork is porous, and corks can shrink or leak as vessels cool and air contracts, drawing outside air in.
- Contaminated air after heating. Air could enter during the cooling period or while the vials were being prepared.
Spallanzani's design addressed the first two directly: an hour of boiling and glass melted shut. The third is the subtle one, and the reason swan-neck flasks later proved more persuasive.
From the laboratory to the tin can
Spallanzani's demonstration that boiled, sealed food stays unspoiled has an obvious practical echo. In the first decade of the nineteenth century, the French confectioner Nicolas Appert developed a method of preserving food by sealing it in glass bottles and heating them in boiling water. In 1810 the French government awarded him a prize of 12,000 francs, and he published L'Art de conserver les substances animales et végétales. The same year, the Englishman Peter Durand took out a patent for using tin-plated iron containers, and commercial canning followed in Britain within a few years.
Appert worked empirically and did not explain why his method worked; he largely attributed it to excluding air. Whether he drew on Spallanzani is not established. But the principle is the same, and the explanation, that heat kills microbes and the seal keeps new ones out, came only with Pasteur's later work. Modern commercial canning of low-acid foods is designed around the most heat-resistant dangerous spores, those of Clostridium botulinum, which is why home canners are advised to use pressure canners rather than boiling-water baths for vegetables and meats.
Pasteur, Pouchet and the end of the debate
Spontaneous generation was revived in the late 1850s by the French naturalist Félix-Archimède Pouchet, who reported that boiled hay infusions exposed to purified air still produced microbes. In 1860 the French Academy of Sciences offered the Alhumbert Prize for experiments that would settle the question. Louis Pasteur won it in 1862. In addition to swan-necked flasks, he carried sealed flasks of sterile broth to different locations and opened them briefly, from dusty city streets to the Jura mountains and the Mer de Glace glacier near Chamonix. Flasks opened in clean mountain air were contaminated far less often than those opened in the lowlands (at the Mer de Glace, only one of 20 flasks clouded), showing that the number of microbes in the air varied with place, which spontaneous generation could not explain.
Cohn's and Tyndall's spore work in the following decade then explained the remaining contradictory results. By the late 1870s biogenesis was secure for practical purposes.
A common misconception: biogenesis and the origin of life
Spallanzani and Pasteur showed that microbes do not arise from broth in days or weeks under ordinary conditions. They did not show that life could never have arisen from non-living chemistry at any time. These are different questions. The modern study of abiogenesis asks how the first self-replicating systems might have formed on the early Earth over very long timescales, under conditions unlike a flask of broth. Experiments such as the 1952 Miller–Urey experiment, which produced amino acids from simple gases and electric sparks, belong to this separate line of research. There is no contradiction between the two.
Modern sterilisation: the direct descendant
Every hospital and microbiology laboratory relies on the logic of Spallanzani's flasks. The autoclave, developed from 1879 by Charles Chamberland, a colleague of Pasteur, uses pressurised steam to reach temperatures above boiling. A standard cycle runs at 121 °C for at least 15 minutes, conditions chosen to destroy bacterial spores. Sealed, sterile packaging, single-use instruments and aseptic technique all follow from the same two principles: kill what is already there, then keep everything else out.
A safe classroom version
A simple, safe adaptation needs only kitchen materials, and nothing needs to be eaten:
- Make a clear broth from a stock cube and hot water.
- Pour equal amounts into several clean glass jars. Leave one open, cover one loosely with foil, and close one with a tight screw lid.
- Stand the closed jars in a pan of simmering water for 20–30 minutes with adult supervision, then let them cool without opening them. Keep one unboiled, open jar as a control.
- Label the jars and leave them at room temperature for a week, recording cloudiness and smell each day.
The open and unboiled jars typically turn cloudy within a few days, while boiled, tightly sealed jars stay clear longer. Do not open cloudy jars indoors; dispose of them sealed in household waste. The exercise reproduces the core comparison Spallanzani made and also shows why technique matters: a jar opened briefly to "check" will often become contaminated.
The takeaway
Spallanzani's sealed-broth experiments demonstrate that sometimes the simplest experimental designs yield the most powerful insights. He used materials available in any laboratory (glass flasks, broth, heat), performed careful variations to isolate the effect of air exposure, and let the data speak. His work didn't settle the spontaneous generation question—that took Pasteur—but it provided strong early experimental evidence that microorganisms do not arise in a properly heated and sealed infusion, and that they come from outside it.
Sources
- Spallanzani Disproves Spontaneous Generation — EBSCO Research (2024) — Detailed account of Spallanzani's experimental methodology
- Germ Theory and Microbiology — SciHub101 — How Spallanzani's work connected to later germ theory
- The Pasteur Swan-Neck Flask Experiment — SciHub101 — The follow-up experiments that solidified the defeat of spontaneous generation
- History of Medicine: Ancient to Modern — SciHub101 — Broader context of how understanding microbes revolutionized medicine
- Spallanzani, L. (1765). Saggio di osservazioni microscopiche concernenti il sistema della generazione dei signori di Needham e Buffon. Modena.
- Spallanzani, L. (1776). Opuscoli di fisica animale e vegetabile. Modena.
- Encyclopaedia Britannica. "Lazzaro Spallanzani." Biography.
- Tyndall, J. (1877). "Further Researches on the Deportment and Vitality of Putrefactive and Infective Organisms from a Physical Point of View." Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, 167, 149–206.
- Lazzaro Spallanzani — Linda Hall Library, Scientist of the Day
- John Turberville Needham — Linda Hall Library, Scientist of the Day
- Pasteur, L. (1862). "Mémoire sur les corpuscules organisés qui existent dans l'atmosphère." Annales des Sciences Naturelles (Zoologie), 4th series, 16, 5–98.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Guideline for Disinfection and Sterilization in Healthcare Facilities (2008, updated).
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What did Spallanzani actually prove with his sealed-broth experiments?
A: Spallanzani showed that infusions boiled for an hour in flasks sealed by melting the glass did not develop microorganisms, while open flasks swarmed with them and loosely corked flasks had fewer. This supported the view that microbes came from outside the broth, not from spontaneous generation within it.
Q: How did Needham try to explain Spallanzani's results?
A: Needham retorted that Spallanzani's hour of boiling had weakened or destroyed the "vegetative force" in the organic matter. By this logic, Spallanzani's sealed flasks didn't disprove spontaneous generation, just showed that heat destroyed the material's capacity for it.
Q: How did Spallanzani show the boiled broth was not "ruined"?
A: He reported that when long-boiled sealed flasks were broken open to the air, microorganisms appeared in them afterward. The heated broth could clearly still support life, so the sterility of the sealed flasks came from keeping contaminants out, not from destroying the broth.
Q: Did Spallanzani's work immediately convince the scientific community?
A: No. The debate over spontaneous generation continued for another century. It took Louis Pasteur's swan-necked flask experiments in the 1860s to finally convince the scientific mainstream, but Spallanzani had already established the conceptual groundwork.
Q: How long would broth remain sterile in Spallanzani's sealed flasks?
A: Sealed and properly boiled flasks stayed free of organisms for as long as Spallanzani observed them, while open flasks swarmed with them within two days. This sustained sterility of sealed broth was the key evidence against spontaneous generation.
Q: Why did people accept spontaneous generation for so long?
A: Spontaneous generation was ancient doctrine, and the alternative—that microscopic creatures existed everywhere in air and water—was unsettling. It suggested disease was invasion by foreign agents, not an individual's constitution. This required a radically different model of health and illness.
Read next:
Follow new articles
Add SciHub101 to your feed reader to see new science and technology stories.
About the Author
SciHub101 is an independent science and technology publication founded and edited by Buğra Sözeri, a software engineer and app developer based in Türkiye. AI tools assist with drafting and research. Source documentation in the existing archive is uneven, and articles are being reviewed and corrected. The Editorial Team byline identifies editorial responsibility; it does not certify specialist or independent human review. Where we compare products, anything built by our own team is labelled as such — see the editorial guidelines and About page for how corrections and disclosures work.
Related Articles


Pasteur's Swan-Neck Flask: Ending Spontaneous Generation
In 1859, Louis Pasteur designed a flask whose curved neck let air in but kept microbes out. The broth stayed sterile until the neck was broken. Here is the full experiment.

Redi's Experiment: The First Controlled Test in Biology
In 1668, Francesco Redi covered jars of meat with gauze and proved maggots come from fly eggs, not from meat itself. Here is how he designed the first controlled experiment in biology.

The Lenski Long-Term Evolution Experiment: Evolution in Real Time
Since 1988, Richard Lenski has grown E. coli for 80,000+ generations. The result: a living record of evolution, including a once-impossible citrate mutation, visible in real time.