Joseph Priestley's Mouse-and-Mint Experiment
In August 1771, Joseph Priestley, an English chemist and clergyman, let a candle burn in a closed volume of air in a glass vessel until the flame went out. The air in the vessel no longer supported combustion. But when he enclosed a sprig of mint in air that a candle had burned out, on 17 August, and tested it again on 27 August, ten days later, something remarkable happened: another candle burned in it with perfect ease. The plant had somehow restored the air's ability to sustain flame.
Emboldened, Priestley turned to animals in 1772. He found that air made unfit to breathe by mice, or by a burning candle, could be made fit again by a growing plant, so that a mouse could live in it. Plants, Priestley concluded, did not simply exhale the same air they inhaled; they changed it, restoring something that breathing animals and burning fires consumed. He didn't know he'd discovered oxygen or photosynthesis, but his experiments opened the door to both.
The "restored air" puzzle
Priestley's experiments were born from a puzzle that had intrigued natural philosophers for decades: what was "air," and what happened to it when you breathed or burned things in a confined space?
By the 18th century, scientists knew that air was necessary for life and combustion. Seal an animal in a jar, and it eventually suffocates. Light a candle in a jar, and it burns until the air is "spent" and the flame dies. But what made air "good" and what turned it "bad"? Was air a single substance, or a mixture? What exactly did breathing animals and flames extract from it?
Phlogiston theory — the prevailing chemical framework of the time — held that combustible materials contained a substance called "phlogiston." When something burned, it released phlogiston into the air, and eventually the air became saturated with it and could support no more burning. By analogy, breathing animals likewise exhaled phlogiston-laden air.
Priestley accepted phlogiston theory, which shaped how he interpreted his results. But his experimental observations were reproducible, and they pointed beyond the theory's explanatory power.
The mint-and-candle experiment
On 17 August 1771, Priestley enclosed a sprig of mint in air in which a candle had been allowed to burn out. Standard expectation: the candle dies, the air is spent, and nothing more happens. But Priestley wondered: could anything restore the air?
He left the setup alone. On 27 August, ten days later, he tested the air again with another candle.
To his surprise, the candle burned perfectly well. The plant had restored something to the air that allowed combustion again.
He repeated the experiment with different plants and intervals, and the restoration usually worked, though not always. Priestley did not identify the role of light; that discovery belongs to the Dutch-born physician Jan Ingenhousz in 1779, discussed below.
Priestley proposed a hypothesis: plants restore to the air whatever breathing animals and burning candles remove. We now know the missing ingredient to be oxygen, but Priestley lacked the chemical framework to name it correctly.
The mouse experiment
Priestley then tried a more dramatic test in 1772. He fouled air by keeping mice in a closed volume of it until they could no longer live in it. He then introduced a sprig of mint and found that, after a time, the air had been restored enough that a candle would burn in it and a mouse could live in it.
The implication was clear: plants did something to the air that made it fit for animal life. They didn't simply regenerate a "life force"; they changed the atmosphere around them.
What matters is the comparison. In air fouled by breathing, a mouse could not live, and in similar air restored by a plant, it could. Priestley's trials were informal by modern standards, with no standardized timings or replicate counts, so the result is best read as a striking qualitative demonstration rather than a measurement.
Interpreting results through a phlogiston lens
Here's where Priestley's theoretical framework limited his insight. He was a committed phlogiston theorist. He interpreted his plant experiments as evidence that plants absorbed phlogiston from the air, "dephlogisticating" it and restoring its ability to support combustion and life.
We now know his interpretation was backwards. Plants don't absorb phlogiston; they produce oxygen (which doesn't exist in phlogiston theory). They do this by splitting water molecules using light energy—photosynthesis. But Priestley's mistake didn't undermine his observations; it just meant his explanation was wrong even as his data were right.
Priestley called restored air "good" or wholesome air. His later term, "dephlogisticated air," was the name he used in 1775 for the gas he had released in August 1774 by heating mercury oxide. That gas was oxygen, though he never accepted Lavoisier's interpretation of it. It would take Antoine Lavoisier, who was also working on the chemistry of combustion and respiration in the 1770s and 1780s, to overturn phlogiston theory and correctly identify the gas as an element.
The oxygen cycle emerges
Even misinterpreted, Priestley's findings were profound. He had demonstrated that growing plants can chemically restore air depleted by burning and breathing, although he could not say under what conditions. He had shown that the atmosphere wasn't a static medium but a dynamic system where animals and flames consume something essential and plants can regenerate it.
This hinted at an oxygen cycle: animals breathe and plants restore; plants grow in light and animals grow by consuming plant material. The circle was closed, even if Priestley didn't have the precise chemistry to describe it.
Over the next two decades, as phlogiston theory collapsed and Lavoisier built a new chemistry based on oxygen and other elements, Priestley's observations fit perfectly into the emerging framework. Photosynthesis—the process by which plants use light energy to turn carbon dioxide and water into sugars while releasing oxygen—explained why plants restored air. Respiration—the reverse process, where organisms consume oxygen and produce carbon dioxide—explained why animals and flames depleted it.
Publication and reception
Priestley published his findings in the paper "Observations on Different Kinds of Air," which was read to the Royal Society in installments in 1772 and printed in the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society. The Royal Society awarded him its Copley Medal in 1773. The results were therefore on record and recognized, but they were hard to interpret. Priestley's own explanation rested on phlogiston, and his plant results were inconsistent from trial to trial, as he himself later admitted. A coherent explanation needed Lavoisier's oxygen chemistry and Ingenhousz's discovery that light matters, both of which came later.
Misconceptions and limits
A common misunderstanding is that Priestley "discovered photosynthesis." He didn't, in the modern sense. He showed that plants restore air in light, but he had no idea of the mechanism: the light-dependent splitting of water molecules, the electron transport chains, the production of sugars. The detailed biochemistry of photosynthesis came later, in the 20th century.
Another misconception is that Priestley's mouse experiment proved plants and animals are perfectly balanced in a closed ecosystem. In reality, Priestley's enclosed vessels were artificial environments. In the open air, plants and animals do recycle atmospheric gases, but the balance is complex and depends on biomass, light availability, and many other factors.
It's also worth noting that Priestley was careful but only partly quantitative by modern standards. He had a rough numerical test for the "goodness" of air, described below, but he did not weigh reactants and products the way Lavoisier did. He observed and reasoned. This observational approach was enormously valuable, but it left room for alternative explanations until Lavoisier began to measure gases with precision.
Who Joseph Priestley was
Joseph Priestley (1733–1804) was born near Birstall in Yorkshire into a family of Dissenters, Protestants who did not conform to the Church of England. Dissenters were barred from Oxford and Cambridge, so Priestley trained at the Daventry Academy and became a minister and teacher. His scientific career was, in a sense, a sideline. He wrote on grammar, history, education and theology, and he was a prominent political radical who supported the American and French Revolutions.
He came to chemistry partly by accident. In 1767 he took a post as minister of Mill Hill Chapel in Leeds and lived next to a brewery. The layer of gas that hung over the fermenting vats, which chemists then called "fixed air" (carbon dioxide), gave him a ready supply to experiment with. In 1772 he published a short pamphlet describing how to dissolve fixed air in water, producing what we would call soda water. That same year he published the long paper on different kinds of air that contains the mint and mouse experiments.
Priestley's earlier work, The History and Present State of Electricity (1767), had been encouraged by Benjamin Franklin, whom he met in London. Franklin remained a friend and correspondent of Priestley for years afterward.
Priestley's apparatus: the pneumatic trough
Much of Priestley's skill was technical. He collected and stored gases using a pneumatic trough: a basin of water, or later mercury, with an inverted glass vessel full of liquid standing in it. Gas bubbled in from below and displaced the liquid, so it could be trapped, moved and tested without mixing with room air. Using mercury rather than water was a key improvement, because gases that dissolve in water, such as ammonia and hydrogen chloride, could then be collected. Priestley isolated about ten gases this way, including nitric oxide, nitrous oxide, ammonia, hydrogen chloride and sulfur dioxide, as well as oxygen.
He also developed tests for the "goodness" of air. The most important was the nitrous air test: when nitric oxide is mixed with ordinary air over water, it reacts with the oxygen and the volume shrinks. The more the volume shrinks, the more oxygen the sample contains. This gave him an approximate, numerical way to compare samples, which was a step toward the measurement that Lavoisier would later make central to chemistry.
Why mice?
Using mice was practical. They were small enough to fit inside a jar and cheap, and their behaviour gave a sensitive indicator of whether air could support life. His reports describe placing a mouse in a measured quantity of air and recording how long it lived. In 1775, when testing the gas he obtained from mercury oxide, he wrote that he put a mouse into a quantity of it such that, "had it been common air, it would have died in a quarter of an hour; it lived, at two different times, a whole hour, and was taken out quite vigorous." It was the mouse, as much as the candle, that told him this new air was better than common air.
These experiments involved animal suffering and deaths that would not be acceptable as classroom demonstrations today. They are of historical interest, but no one should repeat them.
The discovery of oxygen in 1774
The mint experiment is often treated as the discovery of oxygen. It was not. Priestley isolated oxygen separately on 1 August 1774, at Bowood House in Wiltshire, where he was then working as librarian and companion to the Earl of Shelburne. He used a large burning lens, about a foot across, to focus sunlight on a sample of red mercury oxide ("mercurius calcinatus") inside a glass vessel. A gas was given off in which a candle burned with a remarkably vigorous flame.
Priestley described the new gas, in a paper read to the Royal Society in March 1775, as "dephlogisticated air," meaning air that had been stripped of phlogiston and so could absorb more of it from a burning candle. He even breathed some of it himself and reported feeling light and easy afterwards, and he speculated that it might become a luxury. In October 1774 he travelled to Paris with Shelburne and described his results to Antoine Lavoisier over dinner.
The Swedish apothecary Carl Wilhelm Scheele had produced the same gas independently, probably in 1771 or 1772, calling it "fire air," but his book was delayed by his publisher until 1777. Lavoisier repeated and extended the experiments and, by the late 1770s, interpreted the gas as an element that combines with substances when they burn. He later named it oxygène. Scholars still debate who deserves credit for "discovering" oxygen, which is a good lesson in how discovery depends on both isolation and interpretation.
Ingenhousz: light and green leaves
Priestley's plant results were frustratingly inconsistent. Sometimes plants restored the air and sometimes they seemed to make it worse. By the late 1770s he reported difficulties in repeating his earlier findings. The explanation came from Jan Ingenhousz, a Dutch-born physician who worked at the Austrian court and had become famous for smallpox inoculation.
In the summer of 1779, in southern England, Ingenhousz carried out hundreds of experiments and published them as Experiments upon Vegetables, Discovering Their Great Power of Purifying the Common Air in the Sun-shine, and of Injuring It in the Shade and at Night. The title summarises the findings. Plants restored air only in sunlight, not merely in warmth. Only the green parts did so. In the dark, plants behaved like animals, making the air worse. He collected the bubbles rising from submerged leaves in light and showed with the nitrous air test that they were rich in the "good" air.
Further pieces of the puzzle followed. In 1782 the Genevan pastor Jean Senebier argued that the process depends on "fixed air" (carbon dioxide) taken up by the plant. In 1804 Nicolas-Théodore de Saussure showed by careful weighing that the gain in a plant's mass came from carbon dioxide and water, not mainly from soil. Together these results produced the outline that every student now learns: carbon dioxide plus water, in light, gives sugar plus oxygen.
Where the oxygen actually comes from
There is a further twist that the eighteenth century could not have guessed. It is natural to assume that the oxygen plants release comes from carbon dioxide, since CO₂ goes in and O₂ comes out. In 1941 Samuel Ruben, Martin Kamen and colleagues used water labelled with the heavy oxygen isotope oxygen-18 and showed that the oxygen released in photosynthesis comes from water, not carbon dioxide. Earlier, Cornelis van Niel had argued from his studies of sulfur bacteria that photosynthesis splits a hydrogen donor, which for plants is water. The candle in Priestley's jar was, in the end, burning oxygen split from water molecules by the mint's chloroplasts.
Priestley's later life and stubbornness
Priestley's political and religious views made him enemies. In July 1791, a mob in Birmingham, angered by a dinner held to celebrate the anniversary of the storming of the Bastille, burned his house, church and laboratory in what became known as the Priestley Riots. He moved to London and then, in 1794, emigrated to the United States, settling in Northumberland, Pennsylvania, where he died in 1804.
He never abandoned phlogiston. In 1796 he published Considerations on the Doctrine of Phlogiston, and the Decomposition of Water, still defending the old theory long after most chemists had adopted Lavoisier's system. His persistence is sometimes treated as a flaw, but it also shows that experimental skill and theoretical judgement are separate talents, and that an accurate observer can hold onto a failing explanation.
A safe classroom version
The core idea can be shown without any animals:
- Place a sprig of a water plant such as Elodea (pondweed) in a test tube or beaker of water with a pinch of sodium bicarbonate, which supplies dissolved carbon dioxide.
- Put it under a bright lamp and count the bubbles rising from cut stems per minute.
- Move the lamp farther away or cover the beaker and count again. Fewer bubbles in dim light reproduce Ingenhousz's key finding.
- Collect the gas in an inverted test tube full of water. With enough gas, a glowing splint pushed into it may reignite, the same test Priestley used in spirit.
Many school biology curricula use this pondweed experiment because it directly links light intensity to the rate of oxygen production.
The takeaway
Joseph Priestley showed that plants were not passive decorations but active chemical agents in the atmosphere. His observation that a plant could restore air enough to relight a candle or sustain a mouse was simple, elegant, and profound. He couldn't explain the mechanism—phlogiston theory was wrong—but his basic observations held up. They hinted at a vast cycle of gas exchange between the living and the atmosphere, a cycle that was quickly understood once oxygen chemistry replaced phlogiston. His work opened the modern era of understanding photosynthesis, respiration, and the atmosphere.
Sources
- Joseph Priestley and the Discovery of Oxygen — American Chemical Society — National Historic Chemical Landmark
- Joseph Priestley — Wikipedia — Biographical dates
- How Photosynthesis Works: The Process That Feeds the Planet — SciHub101 — Modern explanation of plant photosynthesis and the oxygen cycle
- History of Medicine: Ancient to Modern — SciHub101 — Broader history-of-science context
- Priestley, J. (1772). "Observations on Different Kinds of Air." Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, 62, 147–264.
- Priestley, J. (1775). Experiments and Observations on Different Kinds of Air, Vol. 2. London: J. Johnson.
- Ingenhousz, J. (1779). Experiments upon Vegetables. London: P. Elmsly and H. Payne.
- Priestley, J. (1775). "An Account of Further Discoveries in Air." Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, 65, 384–394 (the letter of 15 March 1775 naming "dephlogisticated air").
- Ruben, S., Randall, M., Kamen, M., & Hyde, J. L. (1941). "Heavy Oxygen (O18) as a Tracer in the Study of Photosynthesis." Journal of the American Chemical Society, 63(3), 877–879.
- Science History Institute. "Joseph Priestley." Biography.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What did Priestley's mint experiment demonstrate?
A: Priestley showed that a candle that couldn't burn in "spent" air would burn again if a sprig of mint had been left in that air for ten days (17 to 27 August 1771). The plant restored something to the air that allowed combustion, later understood to be oxygen.
Q: Did Priestley know he had discovered oxygen?
A: Not in the mint experiment. He isolated oxygen separately on 1 August 1774 by heating mercury oxide and later called it "dephlogisticated air," interpreting it through phlogiston theory. He never accepted Lavoisier's interpretation of it as an element. That understanding came after Lavoisier overturned phlogiston theory.
Q: What was the mouse experiment and what did it show?
A: In 1772 Priestley kept mice in a closed volume of air until it could no longer support them (air "injured by respiration," in his terms). When a sprig of mint was introduced and the air was left to recover, a mouse could live in it again, showing that plants restored air for animal use.
Q: How did light affect Priestley's plant experiments?
A: Priestley did not establish the role of light, and his plant results were inconsistent from trial to trial. It was Jan Ingenhousz in 1779 who showed that plants restore air only in light and only through their green parts, while in darkness they make the air worse, like animals.
Q: Why did the scientific establishment take so long to accept Priestley's results?
A: His results were recognized at the time (he received the Royal Society's Copley Medal in 1773), but they were hard to interpret. His phlogiston-based explanation was wrong, and his plant results were inconsistent until Ingenhousz identified the role of light in 1779 and Lavoisier's oxygen chemistry provided a framework.
Q: How did Priestley's experiments connect to photosynthesis?
A: Priestley showed that growing plants can restore air so that it again allows combustion and supports animal life. We now know this is oxygen, produced during photosynthesis. His experiments were an important early clue to the exchange of gases between plants, animals and the atmosphere, although the role of light and the chemistry came from later work.
Read next:
Follow new articles
Add SciHub101 to your feed reader to see new science and technology stories.
About the Author
SciHub101 is an independent science and technology publication founded and edited by Buğra Sözeri, a software engineer and app developer based in Türkiye. AI tools assist with drafting and research. Source documentation in the existing archive is uneven, and articles are being reviewed and corrected. The Editorial Team byline identifies editorial responsibility; it does not certify specialist or independent human review. Where we compare products, anything built by our own team is labelled as such — see the editorial guidelines and About page for how corrections and disclosures work.
Related Articles

The Chemistry of Photosynthesis — From Photons to Sugar
How photosynthesis works at the molecular level — the light reactions, Z-scheme, electron transport chain, Calvin cycle, and why quantum coherence may be involved.

How Photosynthesis Works — The Process That Feeds the Planet
Photosynthesis takes sunlight, water, and CO₂ and produces sugar and oxygen. It powers nearly every food chain on Earth — and it produced the air you're breathing right now.

Lavoisier's Combustion Experiments: How Oxygen Ended the Phlogiston Era
In the 1770s, Antoine Lavoisier used the sealed flask and the balance to prove combustion consumes oxygen, conservation of mass holds, and phlogiston does not exist.
