William Harvey's Blood Circulation Experiments
For well over a thousand years, physicians followed Galen in believing that the body contained two largely separate blood systems: one in the veins, carrying blood made in the liver from food, and another in the arteries, carrying blood charged with "vital spirit" by the heart. Blood, in this model, ebbed and flowed and was consumed where it was used. Then in 1628, William Harvey published a small, audacious book that overturned this framework. Through ligatures tied around arms, careful observations of animal hearts, and logical arithmetic, Harvey demonstrated that blood circulated—pumped by the heart in a continuous loop through the body and back again.
The Galenic inheritance: blood made, not circulated
Galen's model — the anatomical and physiological framework developed by the Roman physician Galen in the 2nd century AD, which dominated European medicine for well over a thousand years — held that blood originated in the liver (where it was "concocted" from food) and was distributed outward to the body for nourishment. The heart was thought to produce a separate "vital spirit" that animated life, rather than to pump blood around a circuit. Veins and arteries were imagined as tubes through which blood ebbed and flowed, not as parts of a circuit.
This model made intuitive sense to medieval and Renaissance physicians. The liver is large, sits near the stomach, and seemed like a plausible "workshop" for processing food into blood. The heart was seen as a furnace of warmth and emotion, not as a mechanical pump. Most importantly, no one could see the capillaries that connect arteries to veins, so the circuit appeared broken.
By Harvey's time (he was born in 1578), human dissection had become more common, but Galenic anatomy still dominated. Medical students learned Galen, professors lectured Galen, and challenging Galen was professional and intellectual heresy. Harvey, however, was willing to use his own eyes and hands.
Harvey's ligature experiments
Harvey's key experiments used simple ligature experiments—tying a bandage around a living arm to restrict blood flow and observing what happened. The method was straightforward but required careful observation, and it gave different results depending on how tight the band was.
When Harvey tied a ligature moderately tight around an arm, as for bloodletting, he noticed that the veins below the ligature (toward the hand) swelled and became engorged. If Galen were correct—if veins carried blood outward from the liver to be used up in the limb—then tightening a band should have starved the part below it. Instead, the opposite occurred: blood pooled below, swelling the veins like water behind a dam.
When he drew the ligature very tight, the effect was different. The artery swelled and throbbed immediately above the band, while beyond it no pulse could be felt at the wrist or anywhere else. The tight band was blocking blood flow from the heart outward through the arteries.
Harvey drew a logical conclusion: a moderate band lets arterial blood in but stops venous blood from leaving, and a tight band stops arterial blood too. Blood must therefore travel from the heart down the arteries, somehow cross from arteries to veins in the tissues, and return to the heart through the veins—a continuous circuit.
The heart as a pump: the quantitative argument
Harvey also performed detailed dissections and vivisections of living animals—dogs, pigs, eels, frogs, snakes and fish among them—to observe the beating heart directly. He even reports seeing the heart pulsating in wasps, hornets and flies with the aid of a magnifying glass. He then did something no one had done: he put numbers on the heart's output. These were estimates, not measurements, and he chose them deliberately low. The result was staggering.
If the heart ejected even a modest amount per beat, then the total volume pumped in a short time would be much greater than the total amount of blood in the body. This meant blood couldn't be made fresh at each location and consumed where it sat; it had to be recycled, moving in a continuous loop.
This arithmetic alone undermined Galenic theory. Harvey concluded, in the Willis translation of his book, that "the blood in the animal body is impelled in a circle, and is in a state of ceaseless motion." The heart was a pump, not a furnace.
De Motu Cordis (1628) and the revolution it sparked
In 1628, after more than a decade of work, Harvey published his findings in Frankfurt in a short book titled De Motu Cordis et Sanguinis in Animalibus ("On the Motion of the Heart and Blood in Animals"). It was written in Latin, the language of scholarship, and ran to only 72 pages. It contained very few illustrations, relying instead on clear reasoning and the logical force of his observations.
The book was revolutionary precisely because it was logical and tied to direct observation. Harvey wasn't invoking authority or citing ancient texts; he was saying: "Here is what I see in the body. Here is what the measurements tell us. Here is what must follow from these facts."
The response was explosive—but not immediately in Harvey's favor. Many physicians attacked him. Some refused to read his work. Others read it and rejected it on principle, because it contradicted Galen. A few younger physicians embraced it, but the medical establishment largely resisted for decades. Harvey's reputation suffered, and it took time for the theory to gain acceptance.
The missing piece: capillaries
There was one major problem with Harvey's theory that he couldn't resolve: if blood travels from arteries to veins through the tissues, where exactly does that transfer happen? He proposed "pores" in the flesh connecting arteries directly to veins, but he couldn't observe them. His logic suggested they must exist, but he lacked the technology to prove it.
In 1661, a few years after Harvey's death, Italian anatomist Marcello Malpighi used a microscope to observe capillaries in the lungs of a frog. The capillaries were real, and they were the missing link in Harvey's circuit. With that confirmation, any lingering doubt about blood circulation dissolved.
Why resistance persisted so long
Even after Harvey's book, even after Malpighi found capillaries, the medical establishment took decades to fully accept blood circulation. Why?
First, Galen's model was woven into the entire framework of medical practice, diagnosis, and treatment. To abandon it meant rethinking disease, therapy, and the very meaning of health. Second, Harvey's evidence was logical and observational, but it lacked the visual confirmation that microscopes would later provide. Third, professional authority and tradition are powerful forces; younger physicians had to prove themselves without contradicting their teachers and mentors.
The transition was gradual. By the late 1600s, most educated physicians accepted circulation, but folk practitioners and older physicians often clung to Galenic bleeding and purging well into the 18th and 19th centuries.
Who Harvey was before the book
William Harvey was born in Folkestone, Kent, in 1578, the eldest son of a prosperous yeoman family. He studied at Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge, and then did what ambitious English medical students of the period often did: he went to Italy. At the University of Padua, then the leading anatomical school in Europe, he studied under Hieronymus Fabricius of Aquapendente and took his doctorate in 1602.
Padua matters to this story for two reasons. First, it was the institution where Andreas Vesalius had taught in the 1530s and 1540s, and where the habit of looking at bodies rather than only reading about them was strongest. Second, Fabricius was working on the structures that would later become one of Harvey's most persuasive pieces of evidence: the small valves inside veins. Fabricius published his description of them in De Venarum Ostiolis ("On the Little Doors of the Veins") in 1603, the year after Harvey left. Fabricius thought the valves slowed blood down so that it would not pool in the extremities. Harvey would later see that their orientation made sense only if blood in the limbs moved toward the heart.
Back in London, Harvey built an establishment career. He became a Fellow of the College of Physicians, physician at St Bartholomew's Hospital, and in 1615 was appointed Lumleian lecturer, a post that required regular public anatomy lectures. His surviving lecture notes from 1616 already contain the idea that blood moves in a circle, which means he spent more than a decade testing and refining the argument before publishing it. He later served as physician to both James I and Charles I. That position is part of why he could survive the controversy: he was attacked as an innovator, but he was not an outsider.
The quantitative argument, in Harvey's own numbers
The arithmetic in De Motu Cordis is often summarized loosely, but the actual numbers Harvey used are worth seeing because they show how cautious he was. In chapter 9, he deliberately chose low estimates so that no critic could accuse him of inflating the result.
He supposed that a fourth, fifth, sixth or even only an eighth of the left ventricle's contents was thrown into the aorta at each contraction, which "would give either half an ounce, or three drachms, or one drachm of blood" per pulse (a drachm is one-eighth of an ounce). He then noted that the heart makes more than a thousand beats in half an hour, and in some people as many as two, three or even four thousand. Even with the smallest figure, a single drachm, a thousand beats move more than ten pounds of blood in half an hour (Harvey's own total is ten pounds five ounces), far more than the whole body is known to contain.
The logic is what historians call a reductio: if the liver had to manufacture that much fresh blood from food, a person would need to eat and digest an impossible amount every hour. No meal could supply it and no vessel could hold it. The only reasonable conclusion was that the same blood returns again and again.
Modern measurements make Harvey's caution look almost comic. A resting adult heart ejects roughly 70 millilitres per beat and about five litres per minute, so the whole blood volume passes through the heart about once a minute at rest. Harvey's lowest figure of one drachm (under 4 millilitres) was an underestimate by more than an order of magnitude, and the conclusion still held. That is the mark of a robust argument: it survives even when the inputs are chosen to work against it.
The vein-valve demonstration anyone can repeat
The most elegant experiment in De Motu Cordis needs nothing but a finger. Harvey illustrated it in the book's few figures, which show a forearm with a band tied above the elbow so the superficial veins stand out and the valves appear as small knots along them.
The procedure works like this:
- Tie a moderate ligature around the upper arm so the veins of the forearm fill and become visible.
- Press one finger on a vein just below a valve, then use a second finger to push the blood along the vein toward the hand (away from the heart).
- The stretch of vein between the valve and your fingers stays empty. Blood cannot flow backward through the valve to refill it.
- Push the blood the other way, toward the heart, and it moves past the valve easily.
- Release the lower finger and the empty segment refills at once, from below.
Harvey drew a quantitative point out of this too. If you repeatedly milk a short segment of vein toward the heart, you can move a surprising amount of blood through it in a short time. Since the valves allow only one direction, that blood must be continually supplied from the arteries via the tissues, and continually delivered back to the heart. The valves that Fabricius saw as brakes were actually one-way gates in a closed loop.
Tight versus loose ligatures
The ligature experiment described earlier came in two strengths, and the difference between them is what made it decisive.
A tight ligature, as used by surgeons before an amputation, cuts off both arteries and veins. The arm below goes pale and cool, and no pulse can be felt at the wrist. Above the band the artery swells and throbs. That showed arterial blood flows outward from the heart toward the limb.
A moderate ligature compresses the superficial veins but not the deeper, thicker-walled arteries. Now the hand flushes, warms, and the veins below the band swell. Blood is still getting in through the arteries, but it cannot get back out through the veins. Released, the swelling drains away toward the heart.
Put the two results together and you have direction: in through the arteries, out through the veins, all in a few minutes. Galen's model had no way to explain why a loose band would fill the hand with blood rather than starve it.
The pulmonary circuit and earlier pioneers
Harvey was not the first person to challenge part of Galen's picture. Galen had taught that some blood seeped from the right side of the heart to the left through invisible pores in the septum, the muscular wall between the ventricles. In the 13th century the physician Ibn al-Nafis, working in Cairo, rejected this and argued that blood must pass from the right ventricle to the lungs and back to the left side, the route now called pulmonary circulation. Whether his commentary influenced Renaissance European anatomists is still debated by historians.
In the 16th century, Michael Servetus described the pulmonary transit in a theological book published in 1553, and the Paduan anatomist Realdo Colombo set out the same idea in his 1559 anatomy text. What none of them did was join the lung circuit to a body-wide circuit and support the whole loop with experiment and measurement. Harvey's contribution was that synthesis: two circuits, one pump, continuous flow, demonstrated rather than asserted.
Harvey also studied fetal circulation, comparative anatomy across many species, and the hearts of cold-blooded animals. He noted that in cold or dying animals the heartbeat slows enough that the order of contraction can be seen: the atria first, then the ventricles. That observation, made on slow, cooled hearts, helped him establish that the active stroke of the heart is contraction (systole), which forces blood out, not expansion that draws it in as many of his predecessors believed.
Critics, Descartes, and the long reply
The most serious opponent was Jean Riolan the Younger, a respected Paris anatomist who had put forward a rival account in his Encheiridium anatomicum of 1648. Harvey had kept a public silence of about two decades before answering him in two essays published together in 1649 as Exercitationes duae anatomicae de circulatione sanguinis. The first essay took Riolan's objections apart point by point; the second also took up Descartes's objections to his account of the heart.
Descartes is an interesting case. He was one of the first major thinkers to endorse circulation publicly, in his Discourse on Method of 1637. But he rejected Harvey's account of how the heart works. Descartes thought the heart was a kind of furnace that heated blood until it expanded and burst outward, with diastole as the active phase. Harvey disagreed, insisting from vivisection that the heart actively contracts like a muscle. On this point Harvey was right and the famous philosopher was wrong, which shows that accepting a conclusion and understanding the mechanism behind it are separate things.
Harvey also suffered practical costs. His friend John Aubrey later wrote that after the book appeared, Harvey's medical practice declined, as patients thought him "crack-brained." Whether or not that account is exact, it captures how professionally risky the claim was.
Common misconceptions about Harvey's work
"Harvey discovered capillaries." He did not. He inferred that some connection between arteries and veins must exist, but he never saw one. Malpighi saw capillaries in frog lung tissue through a microscope in 1661, four years after Harvey's death in 1657.
"Harvey immediately transformed medical treatment." The theory changed physiology long before it changed therapy. Bloodletting, justified by Galenic humoral ideas, remained routine for roughly two more centuries. Knowing how blood moves did not by itself tell physicians what to do about disease.
"Harvey was a rebel who rejected the ancients." Harvey thought of himself as a follower of Aristotle, and his interest in circular motion as a perfect and natural form owed something to Aristotelian philosophy. What he rejected was Galen's specific physiology, not classical learning as a whole.
"The heart was his only evidence." His case rested on several independent lines: the arithmetic, the two kinds of ligature, the vein valves, dissection of many species, and the timing of the heartbeat. Each could be challenged; together they were hard to resist.
What Harvey's method left to modern medicine
Almost every modern cardiovascular procedure depends on the circuit Harvey described. Blood pressure readings work because a cuff on the upper arm, like Harvey's tight ligature, briefly stops arterial flow, and the reading is taken as flow returns. Intravenous drips and blood draws use the veins as the return route to the heart. The idea of cardiac output, the litres per minute the heart pumps, is a direct descendant of his drachms-per-beat calculation. If you want the modern physiology in detail, see our explainer on how the human heart pumps blood.
His method also travelled. Other experiments on this site follow the same pattern of a simple setup plus careful reasoning, from Galileo's inclined plane experiments on motion to Lavoisier's combustion experiments that replaced phlogiston with oxygen. In each case a cheap apparatus and a willingness to measure did more than centuries of commentary.
The takeaway
Harvey's work is a template for how science overturns established belief: careful observation, systematic experimentation (ligatures, dissections, calculations), logical reasoning from evidence, and willingness to propose something radical if the evidence demands it. He didn't invent new technology; he used existing tools in new ways and trusted his eyes and mind to see what was actually happening in the body. His insistence that blood circulates—derived from simple string tied around an arm—demolished a centuries-old edifice and built modern cardiovascular medicine in its place.
Sources
- Harvey, W. (1628). Exercitatio Anatomica de Motu Cordis et Sanguinis in Animalibus. Frankfurt. English translation by Robert Willis, An Anatomical Disquisition on the Motion of the Heart and Blood in Animals (chapters 9, 11, 13 and 14 on the quantitative argument, ligatures, vein valves and conclusion)
- William Harvey — Wikipedia — Biographical dates and career
- How the Human Heart Pumps Blood — SciHub101 — Modern cardiovascular physiology context
- History of Medicine: Ancient to Modern — SciHub101 — Broader medical context and the transition from Galenic to modern medicine
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What did physicians believe about blood before Harvey?
A: They followed Galen's model: blood was made in the liver and consumed throughout the body for nutrition, while a separate "vital spirit" was produced in the heart. Blood was not thought to circulate; it was made and used in place.
Q: How did Harvey's ligature experiment work?
A: Harvey tied a bandage around a living arm. With a moderate ligature the veins below it swelled with blood; with a very tight one the pulse vanished below the band while the artery throbbed above it. Together these results pointed to blood flowing into a limb through the arteries and out through the veins, as part of a continuous circuit.
Q: Why did the medical establishment resist Harvey's theory?
A: Harvey's evidence was logical and observational, but it contradicted more than a thousand years of Galenic medicine. Medical education, practice, diagnosis, and treatment were all built on Galen's model, so accepting circulation meant rethinking everything. Additionally, Harvey couldn't observe capillaries, the final link in the circuit, without a microscope.
Q: How long did it take for physicians to accept blood circulation?
A: Acceptance was gradual. Some younger physicians embraced Harvey's theory within decades, but most of the medical establishment didn't fully accept circulation until the late 1600s, after Marcello Malpighi observed capillaries under a microscope in 1661.
Q: Did Harvey use animals in his experiments?
A: Yes, Harvey performed dissections and vivisections (observations on living animals) on dogs, pigs, eels, frogs, snakes, fish and others, and reported watching the heart pulsate in wasps, hornets and flies through a magnifying glass. He also tied ligatures around human arms and observed the effects. Animal studies were essential to his understanding of how the heart and blood vessels worked.
Q: How did Harvey calculate the volume of blood pumped by the heart?
A: He did not measure it directly. He estimated that each contraction of the left ventricle sent out half an ounce, three drachms or as little as one drachm of blood, and multiplied by more than a thousand beats in half an hour. Even the lowest estimate gave about ten pounds of blood in half an hour, far more than the body contains, which indicated that blood could not be made fresh in place but had to circulate repeatedly.
Q: What did Harvey's vein-valve experiment show?
A: By pressing on a filled forearm vein and pushing blood along it, Harvey showed that blood would move past the valves only toward the heart. A segment emptied toward the hand stayed empty until released from below, proving that venous blood in the limbs flows in one direction, back to the heart.
Q: Was Harvey the first to describe pulmonary circulation?
A: No. Ibn al-Nafis described blood passing through the lungs in the 13th century, and Michael Servetus (1553) and Realdo Colombo (1559) proposed it in Europe. Harvey's achievement was linking the lung circuit to a full body-wide circulation and backing it with experiment and arithmetic.
Read next:
Follow new articles
Add SciHub101 to your feed reader to see new science and technology stories.
About the Author
SciHub101 is an independent science and technology publication founded and edited by Buğra Sözeri, a software engineer and app developer based in Türkiye. AI tools assist with drafting and research. Source documentation in the existing archive is uneven, and articles are being reviewed and corrected. The Editorial Team byline identifies editorial responsibility; it does not certify specialist or independent human review. Where we compare products, anything built by our own team is labelled as such — see the editorial guidelines and About page for how corrections and disclosures work.
Related Articles


How the Heart Works — Anatomy and Function
How the human heart pumps blood: chambers, valves, electrical conduction, cardiac cycle, and the most important diseases and treatments.

How the Human Heart Pumps Blood: A Complete Guide
Your heart beats about 100,000 times a day without a single conscious thought. Here's the remarkable engineering behind it.

How Bones Work: Living Tissue, Remodeling, Marrow, and Why Bone Beats Steel by Weight
A cubic centimeter of compact bone can withstand about 170 megapascals of compressive stress — comparable to reinforced concrete, at a fraction of the weight. But unlike concrete, bone is alive. It has its own blood supply, repairs cracks autonomously, completely replaces its mineral matrix every 10 years, and simultaneously serves as the body's primary calcium reservoir and the factory producing every blood cell in your body. Here is how it all works.

How the Human Heart Works: The Cardiac Cycle Explained
The heart beats more than 100,000 times per day without a single conscious command, regulated by an electrical system so precise that it can be measured from electrodes on the skin. Here is how that system works, from the first spark in the SA node to the pressure wave that reaches your fingertips.