Van Helmont's Willow Tree Experiment
Sometime in the early seventeenth century, a Flemish physician and chemist named Jan Baptist van Helmont planted a willow cutting in a pot of carefully dried and weighed soil and tended it for five years, adding nothing but water. When he pulled the tree out and weighed everything again, the numbers were hard to argue with: the willow had gained roughly 164 pounds, while the soil had lost only about two ounces. Van Helmont concluded that the wood, bark, and roots had come from water rather than from earth. He was only partly right, but the way he reached his answer mattered more than the answer itself. His report, printed after his death in the 1648 collection Ortus Medicinae, is widely treated as one of the first quantitative experiments in biology and as the opening move in a three-century investigation that ended with the modern chemistry of photosynthesis.
The received doctrine: plants feed on earth
For most of recorded history the answer to "what are plants made of?" seemed obvious. Plants grow out of the ground, so they must be eating the ground. Aristotle's tradition treated the soil as a kind of stomach from which roots drew already-prepared food, and farmers' experience seemed to confirm it. Manure and compost made fields productive; repeated cropping "wore out" land; a plant moved into poor soil weakened. If soil was food, every one of those observations made sense.
Few people thought to test whether garden soil actually vanished into the plants growing in it. Van Helmont did. He belonged to the generation of iatrochemists, physicians who wanted to explain the body and nature through chemistry, and he was deeply influenced by Paracelsus while disagreeing with him on many specifics. His own theory of matter was idiosyncratic: he rejected both the four-element scheme and the Paracelsian tria prima and argued instead that water was the fundamental material of most bodies. The willow experiment was designed, in large part, to support that belief. That point is easy to lose. Van Helmont was not a neutral observer who stumbled on a surprise; he set up an experiment to confirm a theory he already held, and the data happened to cooperate.
Who was Jan Baptist van Helmont?
Van Helmont was born in Brussels in 1579 or 1580 (sources differ on the year) into a family of the minor nobility in the Spanish Netherlands. He studied at the University of Leuven, drifted through several disciplines, and eventually took a medical degree. After a period of travel he married Margaret van Ranst, whose family wealth let him retire to an estate at Vilvoorde, near Brussels, and spend his life on private chemical and medical research rather than on a busy practice.
He is best remembered in chemistry for recognizing that there are airlike substances distinct from ordinary air and for coining the word "gas", apparently from the Greek chaos. He described a "gas sylvestre" (wild gas) released by burning charcoal and by fermenting wine or beer, which we now recognize as carbon dioxide. The irony is sharp: the man who first distinguished carbon dioxide as a separate substance had no idea it was the missing ingredient in his willow tree.
Trouble with the Church
Van Helmont's research was carried out under real legal danger. In the early seventeenth century a fierce debate ran across Europe about the "weapon salve," a supposed remedy that healed a wound by treating the weapon that caused it. Van Helmont defended the salve as a natural, magnetic effect rather than a diabolical one, which irritated both physicians and theologians, especially the Jesuit Jean Roberti, who argued the cure worked through demonic agency. In 1621 his treatise De magnetica vulnerum curatione (On the Magnetic Cure of Wounds) was published, reportedly by his enemies and without his approval, and it set off ecclesiastical proceedings.
Accounts differ on how severe the restrictions were. The Linda Hall Library describes him as under investigation by church authorities from 1621 until 1642 and spending much of that time under house arrest, barred from travel and publication, while Wikipedia mentions house arrest for several weeks in 1634 and notes that the trial never reached a conclusion. Either way, the Church's scrutiny is a large part of the reason so little of his work appeared while he was alive. He died on 30 December 1644, and his son, Franciscus Mercurius van Helmont, assembled his manuscripts and published them in Amsterdam in 1648 as Ortus Medicinae. An English translation, Oriatrike, or Physick Refined, followed in 1662.
A medieval precedent: Nicholas of Cusa
Van Helmont was probably not the first to think of weighing a plant and its soil. Around 1450 the German cardinal and philosopher Nicholas of Cusa wrote a short dialogue, Idiota de staticis experimentis ("The Layman on Experiments with Weights"), in which he proposed that weighing things carefully could reveal hidden natural truths. One of his suggestions was nearly identical to the willow experiment: put a known weight of earth in a pot, grow herbs in it, weigh the herbs and the earth afterward, and infer that the plants' weight came mostly from water.
Nicholas never claimed to have performed the test. It was a thought experiment, offered as an example of what measurement might do. Whether van Helmont knew of Cusanus's suggestion is uncertain, though the similarity has led some writers to see it as a possible inspiration.
The experimental design, step by step
Van Helmont's description in Ortus Medicinae is short, but it contains more care than many retellings suggest. Working from published translations, the setup ran as follows:
- Prepared soil. He took 200 pounds of earth that had been dried in a furnace (an oven) and placed it in an earthenware vessel. Drying mattered: moist soil changes weight with every rain, so oven-drying gave him a stable baseline.
- Weighed cutting. He moistened the soil with rainwater and planted a willow trunk, or stem cutting, weighing about 5 pounds. Willows root easily from cuttings, which made them a practical choice.
- Water only. For five years he watered the pot with rainwater or distilled water as needed and added nothing else.
- Dust cover. He covered the vessel with a tin-plated iron plate pierced with many holes, so that water and air could pass but windblown dust could not settle into the soil and inflate its weight.
- Final weighing. After five years he removed the tree and found it weighed about 169 pounds and 3 ounces. He then dried the soil again and reweighed it, finding it about 2 ounces short of the original 200 pounds.
His arithmetic followed directly. The tree had grown by roughly 164 pounds; the soil had lost a couple of ounces. In his words as usually translated, 164 pounds of wood, bark, and roots had "arisen from water alone."
Details people often miss
Two features of the report are frequently dropped from textbook summaries.
First, he did not weigh the fallen leaves. Willows are deciduous, and van Helmont explicitly noted that he had not counted the leaves shed over four autumns. The true amount of plant material produced was therefore larger than 164 pounds. This omission did not weaken his conclusion; it strengthened it, since an even greater gain had come from somewhere other than the soil.
Second, he did not weigh the water. Several modern retellings say he measured the water he added. His published account does not give a water total. He reasoned from the two quantities he did measure, tree and soil, and attributed the difference to the only thing he had deliberately added.
What the numbers really meant
Van Helmont's reasoning was valid as far as it went: the mass did not come from the soil. His mistake was in assuming the only alternative was water. He had shut out dust, but he could not shut out air, and he had no way to know air was relevant.
Modern plant physiology tells us that the dry matter of a plant is dominated by carbon, hydrogen, and oxygen, built into cellulose, lignin, starch, and other organic molecules. Roughly speaking, carbon makes up close to half of the dry weight of wood. That carbon arrives as carbon dioxide drawn into leaves through tiny pores called stomata. Water supplies hydrogen, and some oxygen ends up in the plant from both water and carbon dioxide. The soil contributes mineral nutrients such as nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, calcium, and magnesium, which are indispensable for life but small in total mass. That is why burning a log leaves only a small heap of ash: the ash is roughly the mineral fraction, while the carbon and hydrogen return to the air.
The overall equation of photosynthesis summarizes the trade:
6 CO₂ + 6 H₂O + light energy → C₆H₁₂O₆ + 6 O₂
There is a further twist. Experiments with isotope-labeled water in the twentieth century showed that the oxygen gas released by plants comes from water, not from carbon dioxide. So the oxygen atoms in the water van Helmont poured into his pot largely left as gas, while the bulk of the willow's dry substance was built from carbon fixed out of the air. The water he credited with making the tree was, in a sense, the part most likely to leave it.
For a fuller treatment of the chemistry, see how photosynthesis works.
Correcting van Helmont: 1690s to 1800s
The willow experiment did not settle the question of plant nutrition. It opened it. Over the next century and a half, a series of investigators each supplied one more piece.
John Woodward and water culture (1699)
The English naturalist John Woodward ran experiments in 1691 and 1692, published in the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society in 1699, in which he grew spearmint in different kinds of water: rainwater, river water, water from a drain, and water with garden soil mixed in. The plants in the dirtier, more mineral-rich water grew better than those in purer water. Woodward concluded that plants were nourished by earthy matter carried in water, not by water alone. He was pushing back toward the soil, but in a measured way, and his method of growing plants in liquid is often cited as an early forerunner of hydroponics. His results directly challenged van Helmont's "water alone" claim and correctly hinted that dissolved minerals matter.
Stephen Hales and "Vegetable Staticks" (1727)
The English clergyman Stephen Hales brought systematic measurement to plant physiology in Vegetable Staticks (1727). He measured transpiration, the loss of water from leaves, and root pressure, the force pushing sap up the stem. Crucially, he proposed that plants take in part of their nourishment from the air through their leaves. Hales could not identify which part of the air, but he moved the question out of the pot and into the atmosphere, exactly where van Helmont had not looked.
Joseph Priestley and the mint sprig (1771–1772)
Joseph Priestley found that a candle or a mouse quickly exhausted the air in a sealed jar, but that a sprig of mint placed in the same jar could "restore" the air so that a candle would burn again or a mouse could survive. Plants, in other words, reversed what burning and breathing did to air. The full story is told in our article on Priestley's mouse and mint experiment. Priestley later isolated the gas we call oxygen, though he interpreted it in terms of the phlogiston theory, which Lavoisier's combustion experiments would overturn.
Jan Ingenhousz and the role of light (1779)
Priestley's results were inconsistent because he had not controlled for light. The Dutch physician Jan Ingenhousz, working in England in the summer of 1779, carried out a long series of experiments, more than 500 by most accounts, and showed that only the green parts of plants restored air, and only in sunlight. In darkness plants did the opposite and fouled the air like animals. He published the results in 1779 in Experiments upon Vegetables. Light was now part of the picture.
Jean Senebier and carbon dioxide (1780s)
The Genevan pastor and naturalist Jean Senebier showed that the "air-restoring" activity depended on the presence of what was then called "fixed air," carbon dioxide. He provided extensive evidence that plants consume carbon dioxide and release oxygen, and that more available carbon dioxide meant more oxygen produced. Here, finally, was van Helmont's missing ingredient: the same "gas sylvestre" he had described, now identified as a raw material of plant growth.
Nicolas-Théodore de Saussure closes the books (1804)
Senebier's younger compatriot Nicolas-Théodore de Saussure did what van Helmont had done, only with far better chemistry. In Recherches chimiques sur la végétation (1804) he carefully measured the gases a plant took in and gave off and the change in its dry mass. He showed that the gain in plant mass was larger than the carbon taken from carbon dioxide alone could explain, and that water was also incorporated into the plant's dry matter. He also demonstrated that the small mineral fraction came from the soil and was necessary for healthy growth.
De Saussure's quantitative work is, in effect, the corrected version of the willow experiment. Van Helmont said "water." Woodward added "minerals." Hales added "air." Priestley, Ingenhousz, and Senebier pinned down oxygen, light, and carbon dioxide. De Saussure balanced the equation. The outline of the modern picture of photosynthesis was in place by the early nineteenth century, roughly 150 years after Ortus Medicinae appeared.
Why the experiment mattered
The willow experiment's legacy rests less on its conclusion than on its form.
It made a mass balance. Van Helmont treated the pot as a closed accounting system: weigh what goes in, weigh what comes out, and infer the rest. That habit of conservation-of-mass bookkeeping later became central to chemistry, most famously in Lavoisier's work. Van Helmont applied it to a living organism more than a century earlier.
It let evidence contradict authority. Whatever his theoretical motives, van Helmont reported a result that cut against the dominant soil-as-food doctrine, and he did so with numbers rather than appeals to ancient writers. That shift from inherited authority to measured evidence is the same shift traced in medicine in our overview of the history of medicine.
At the same time, the experiment has obvious limits by modern standards. There was a single tree and no replication. There was no control pot of soil without a plant to check how much soil weight changed on its own. Water inputs were not recorded. The leaves were lost. None of this makes the work trivial, but it does mean the willow is best understood as a brilliant first step, not a finished proof.
Common misconceptions
"Van Helmont discovered photosynthesis." He did not. He knew nothing of the roles of light, leaves, or carbon dioxide in growth, and he did not connect his own "gas sylvestre" to plants. Photosynthesis was pieced together by others between the 1720s and the early 1800s.
"He proved plants are made of water." He believed he had, but the conclusion was wrong. Most of a tree's dry mass comes from carbon dioxide in the air. Water contributes hydrogen and is a large component of fresh weight, but it is not the main building material of wood.
"He measured the water." His published account gives the weights of the soil and the tree, not a water total.
"The soil contributed nothing." The two ounces of lost soil were real, and the minerals they represent are essential. Without nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, and trace elements, the willow would not have grown at all. Soil contributes little mass but a great deal of function.
"It was entirely original." Nicholas of Cusa described almost the same procedure, as a thought experiment, around 1450. Van Helmont's contribution was to actually carry it out and publish numbers.
Using the willow experiment in the classroom
Teachers often present van Helmont's numbers and ask students to explain them before revealing the answer. A few approaches work well:
- Predict, then reveal. Ask students where they think a tree's mass comes from. Record the answers, show the 200-pound and 164-pound figures, and let them argue about what must have happened. Most will choose water, just as van Helmont did, which sets up the discovery of carbon dioxide.
- Critique the design. Ask what is missing: replication, a no-plant control pot, water measurements, the fallen leaves. Students can then redesign the experiment with modern tools, such as a sealed chamber with a carbon dioxide sensor.
- Run a small version. Fast-growing seedlings, such as radish or bean plants, can be grown in pots of dried, weighed soil for a few weeks. Drying and weighing both soil and harvested plants at the end reproduces van Helmont's core finding on a classroom scale. Comparing fresh and oven-dried plant weights also shows how much of a living plant is water.
The experiment's strength as a teaching tool lies partly in the fact that it is wrong in an interesting way. A carefully measured result led a careful person to a reasonable but incomplete conclusion, and it took generations of further measurement to find what he could not see.
The takeaway
Jan Baptist van Helmont spent five years watching a willow grow in a weighed pot of soil, at a time when he was in conflict with church authorities, and produced numbers that overturned the ancient idea that plants eat earth: about 164 pounds of new tree against about two ounces of lost soil. He credited water, and in that he was mistaken; the bulk of the willow's dry substance came from carbon dioxide, a gas he himself had been the first to describe. But by turning a medieval thought experiment into an actual measurement, he set the template for quantitative biology and posed the question that Woodward, Hales, Priestley, Ingenhousz, Senebier, and de Saussure spent the next 150 years answering.
Sources
- Jan Baptist van Helmont — Wikipedia — Overview of van Helmont's life, theory of matter, and the willow experiment
- Joan Baptista van Helmont — Linda Hall Library, Scientist of the Day — Weapon-salve controversy, ecclesiastical investigation 1621–1642, and house arrest
- Jean Roberti — Wikipedia — The Jesuit opponent in the weapon-salve dispute and van Helmont's 1634 arrest
- Van Helmont's willow experiment (translation) — College of St. Benedict / St. John's University — English translation of the passage from Ortus Medicinae, including the 200 lb, 5 lb, and 169 lb 3 oz figures and the dust cover
- van Helmont, Jan — Encyclopedia.com — Biography and context of the experiment
- Van Helmont's Willow Tree Experiment — McGill University Office for Science and Society — Account of the experiment and its implications
- John Woodward (naturalist) — Wikipedia — Spearmint water-culture experiments published in 1699
- Stephen Hales — Wikipedia — Vegetable Staticks (1727), transpiration, root pressure, and air as plant nourishment
- Jan Ingenhousz — Wikipedia — 1779 experiments establishing the role of light and green tissue
- Jean Senebier — Wikipedia — Evidence that plants consume carbon dioxide and release oxygen
- Saussure's Research on Plant Metabolism — EBSCO Research Starters — Recherches chimiques sur la végétation (1804) and the incorporation of water and CO₂ into plant mass
- Nicolas-Théodore de Saussure — Wikipedia — Biography and quantitative plant chemistry
- How Photosynthesis Works: The Process That Feeds the Planet — SciHub101 — Modern understanding of plant growth and photosynthesis
- History of Medicine: Ancient to Modern — SciHub101 — Broader context of the shift from authority-based to evidence-based science
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What did van Helmont's willow tree gain in mass over the five years? A: The willow went from about 5 pounds to about 169 pounds 3 ounces, a gain of roughly 164 pounds (about 74 kilograms), while the 200 pounds of oven-dried soil lost only about 2 ounces. He did not even count the leaves the tree shed over four autumns.
Q: When was the willow tree experiment published? A: It appeared in Ortus Medicinae, published in Amsterdam in 1648 by his son Franciscus Mercurius van Helmont, four years after van Helmont's death in 1644. An English translation, Oriatrike, followed in 1662. The experiment itself was run earlier, but he left no exact date.
Q: Was van Helmont the first to think of this experiment? A: Probably not. Around 1450 Nicholas of Cusa described a nearly identical thought experiment, weighing earth and herbs grown in it, in Idiota de staticis experimentis. Whether van Helmont knew of it is uncertain. His achievement was actually performing it.
Q: Why couldn't van Helmont publish his work during his lifetime? A: His defense of the "weapon salve" as a natural cure led to ecclesiastical proceedings after a 1621 treatise on the subject was published. The Linda Hall Library describes him as under church investigation from 1621 to 1642, with much of that time under house arrest and a ban on publishing; other accounts stress a shorter house arrest in 1634. His collected works appeared only after his death.
Q: Was van Helmont right that the tree came from water? A: Only partly. Most of a tree's dry mass is built from carbon taken from atmospheric carbon dioxide through photosynthesis. Water supplies hydrogen and makes up much of a living tree's fresh weight, and the soil supplies small but essential minerals.
Q: Who completed the picture after van Helmont? A: John Woodward (1699) showed dissolved minerals help growth, Stephen Hales (1727) argued plants feed partly from air, Joseph Priestley (1770s) showed plants restore air, Jan Ingenhousz (1779) showed light and green parts are required, Jean Senebier identified carbon dioxide as the input, and Nicolas-Théodore de Saussure (1804) quantified the uptake of both CO₂ and water.
Q: Why didn't van Helmont realize that air also contributed to plant growth? A: He had no way to weigh the gas exchange of a living plant, and no one yet knew leaves absorb carbon dioxide. Ironically, he had identified carbon dioxide himself as "gas sylvestre" from burning charcoal and fermentation, but he never linked it to plant growth.
Q: How is the experiment used in schools today? A: Teachers use it to expose the common belief that plants get their mass from soil. Students predict the outcome, critique the design, which lacked replication, a control pot, and water records, and often run a small version with fast-growing seedlings in weighed, dried soil.
Read next:
Follow new articles
Add SciHub101 to your feed reader to see new science and technology stories.
About the Author
SciHub101 is an independent science and technology publication founded and edited by Buğra Sözeri, a software engineer and app developer based in Türkiye. AI tools assist with drafting and research. Source documentation in the existing archive is uneven, and articles are being reviewed and corrected. The Editorial Team byline identifies editorial responsibility; it does not certify specialist or independent human review. Where we compare products, anything built by our own team is labelled as such — see the editorial guidelines and About page for how corrections and disclosures work.
Related Articles

How Astronauts Survive in Space: Life Support Systems Explained
An astronaut in a spacesuit orbiting Earth faces four immediate threats: the vacuum of space (zero pressure, instant death in seconds without suit), extreme temperature swings (−150°C in shadow, 150°C in sunlight), intense radiation (solar wind, cosmic rays), and hypoxia (lack of oxygen). The Environmental Control and Life Support System (ECLSS) on spacecraft manages all four through oxygen generation, carbon dioxide removal, water recycling, temperature regulation, and pressure maintenance. The International Space Station recycles 90 percent of water and generates oxygen through electrolysis. Deep-space missions to Mars will require even more sophisticated recycling: current ECLSS efficiency is insufficient for 2-year Mars transit. This article examines how astronauts survive in space, the engineering of life support, and the challenges of keeping humans alive in the harshest environment.

How Climate Change Is Affecting Your Daily Life
Climate change is not a future event that will arrive later. It is already changing the price of your coffee, the length of your allergy season, the cost of your home insurance, the availability of water in your tap, and the heat outside your window. The effects are measurable, attributed to specific climate mechanisms by peer-reviewed science, and accumulating across every aspect of daily life in 2026. This article maps the concrete pathways — with numbers — from global warming to your daily experience.

Countries with the Most Freshwater Resources (Ranked)
Brazil has the world's largest total renewable freshwater resources — approximately 8,647 cubic kilometers per year, more than any other country and roughly 20 percent of the global total. Russia is second at 4,525 km³/year, Canada third at 2,860 km³/year. But total volume is only part of the story: Canada's per-capita freshwater availability is 36 times higher than China's. And water stress — not total availability — is the defining water challenge of the twenty-first century. This ranking covers the top 20 countries by total renewable freshwater resources, sourced from FAO AQUASTAT, with per-capita comparison and analysis of global water scarcity.

Mpemba Effect — Does Hot Water Freeze Faster?
Can hot water really freeze faster than cold water? The Mpemba effect is one of physics' weirdest puzzles — here's what 60 years of research reveals.